Wire In The Blood

News-Press circulation figures are declining, and what exactly is Other Paid Circulation?

The trilling wire in the blood/sings below inveterate scars/appeasing long-forgotten wars.”T.S. Elliot’s Four Quartets

Some would say local interest is high for the audited circulation figures for the Santa Barbara News-Press, due out October 30. The N-P, like virtually all dailies in the United States, has had declining numbers since 2004 — and has been claiming a daily circulation of 41,000 in each of their many press releases since July 6. But the accurate figures are more complicated.

The last reported figures for News-Press circulation, as of March 31, 2006, reveal a Total Average Paid Circulation of 42,375 Sunday, 42,145 Monday through Friday. Buried within those two impressive numbers, there is a component labeled “Other Paid Circulation,” which for the N-P is 4,505 Mon-Fri, and 1,551 Sunday. These are copies sold in bulk to hotels, employee programs, schools, and other third party sponsors.

Advertisers have recently come to realize a great deal of “padding” could be obtained via these seemingly worthy distribution outlets. As such, from the September 19 edition of Editor and Publisher:

While these techniques are not outright fraud as the [2004] misstatements of circulation figures were, we felt aggressive use of some of these lower-quality techniques would signal a problem with circulation and would therefore pose future risk to advertising rate stability,” wrote analysts in the study. [The study referenced is by Prudential Equity Research of the top 50 papers in the U.S. ]

If national trends are any indication, A Local Daily will have little justification to initiate its annual rate increase, in spite of the “setting the record straight” realpolitick of A Local Blonde during the height of the N-P diaspora.

Virtually all the big players on the national daily newspaper scene are going to take a hit on circulation, according to E&P’s early look at the Audit Bureau of Circulations figures:

Earlier this week, E&P reported that overall circulation data for the upcoming FAS-FAX are trending much like past reporting periods, with industry sources expecting daily down 2.5% and Sunday down 3%, and some major metros are reporting record losses. Now we have the actual numbers for several papers.

I venture few of those national papers had a city wide effort to cancel their subscriptions, or citizen protests outside their offices to add to the Diminishment of the Daily paper.

And from an E&P story on the 2005 Prudential report:

In the most recent study, Prudential found that other paid circulation, which is comprised of hotel, newspapers-in-education (NIE), employee, and third-party sales copies, was up 6.9%. As a contrast, for the period ending September 2004, other-paid circulation was up 34.2%. However, the report notes that even though there’s a reduction in the reliance in other paid circ, the category is still “stemming the losses in home delivery and single-copy sales.”Overall, total daily circ decreased 2.7% in March when compared to the same period last year. Home delivered copies dropped 2.7%. Discounted copies were up 85%. Single-copy sales slipped 7.1%. This category acts as a barometer for the health of the industry because “it’s the most basic example of a consumer actively seeking out the newspaper,” the report said.

It must be said that giving away papers ain’t no bad thing; for the past 20 years The Independent has pioneered that concept in Santa Barbara. As the foundation of our economic viability, our company has treated free circulation seriously, subscribing to a VAC, an independent auditing company for the same amount of time. We are the only audited freebie in town.

Keeping accurate track of numbers has eluded A Local Daily paper for quite some time, in spite of the historical record [a great place to begin is here, for an exhaustive examination of the N-P antecedents], as evidenced by the erroneous tagline on the front page Banner, “Our 151st Year.” The origin of what is now called the “Santa Barbara News-Press” properly begins October 20, 2000.

Contest: Everyone In the Pool! My pick for the final audit number (this will be the total number for Santa Barbara, Goleta, Carp, Montecito, Summerland, Buellton/Santa Ynez, Gaviota): 38,576

The reader’s entry closest to the actual total will win a cool prize, and be memorialized in some nifty, as yet undetermined fashion — probably not a subscription to A Local Daily. Contest ends October 29, 12 am (or when the actual results are made public).

301x247_wire_photogallery_01.jpgThe name of this piece is: Lest any unsuspecting SBMB reader wrongly consider Club Reporter a verse-spouting repository of all things culture‘d, I just happen to love the eponymous BBC America series, starring the ab fab Robson Green. And the quote is apt.

To submit a comment on this article, email or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email

event calendar sponsored by:

Newly Restored Wetlands Opens Public Trails

North Campus Open Space near UCSB is seeing wildlife returning already.

Mental Health Experts Consider More Psychiatric Beds

Hospital leaders are in talks with county Behavioral Wellness and Sheriff's Office.

Report on Disasters Praised, Criticized

A representative with Montecito's volunteer responders found the report lacking.

Bellosguardo Fundraiser Draws Big Donors and Heavy Criticism

The nonprofit foundation, set up to fulfill Huguette Clark's legacy, also faces a legal challenge.

Arts and Honors Scholarship Deadlines Approach

High school seniors can now apply to S.B. Scholarship Foundation for financial awards.