• CREATE AN ACCOUNT
  • LOG.IN
  • CONTENTS
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • ARCHIVE
  • INFO | ADVERTISING | CONTACT US

  • Home
  • News
    • Business
    • NewsFlash
  • A&E
    • Movie Times
    • TV Listings
    • A&E Blog
    • Art Galleries
    • Best Bets
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Voices
    • Letters
    • In Memoriam
  • Events
    • Today
    • Search
    • Submit
    • Best Bets
  • Living
    • Travel
    • Sports
    • Peeps
  • Food & Drink
    • All Restaurants
    • Delivery
    • All Bars & Clubs
    • Drink Specials
    • Open Now
  • Outdoors
    • Outside Insider
    • Spotlight On
    • Features
  • Classifieds
    • Real Estate
    • Jobs
    • Autos
  • Personals
  • Obits

Paul Wellman

Judge William Kocol


Cappello Seeks Sanctions Against Teamsters

Claims NLRB Attorneys Failed to Provide Critical E-mail Evidence


Thursday, September 6, 2007
By Nick Welsh (Contact)
Article Tools
Print friendly
E-mail story
Contact an Editor
iPod friendly
Comments
Bookmark This
del.icio.us. del.icio.us.
Digg! Digg!
furl furl
google google
newsvine newsvine
reddit reddit
technorati technorati
Facebook Facebook
Yahoo! My Web 2.0 Yahoo!

Attorney Barry Cappello—representing the Santa Barbara News-Press and its owner Wendy P. McCaw—is asking Judge William Kocol to impose sanctions against the Teamsters Union and their attorneys for failing to provide documents they had requested as part of the pre-trial discovery process.

The document under contention during the News-Press-National Labor Relations Board hearing this morning was the “Rock-the-House” e-mail written by former News-Press reporter and union activist Tom Schultz last August in which Schultz celebrated a march by union supporters in the newsroom to then-acting publisher Travis Armstrong. The marchers delivered Armstrong a list of demands and then marched back. Many were subsequently issues letters of reprimand and notified they would be suspended. (None of those suspensions were ever enforced, however, but the letters of reprimand constitute one of the many allegations of federal labor law violations filed against the News-Press by the NLRB.)

<em>News-Press</em> attorney Barry Cappello
Click to enlarge photo

Paul Wellman

News-Press attorney Barry Cappello

The NLRB hearing on those allegations is now taking place at the federal Bankruptcy Court, a building that’s owned by McCaw. Cappello contends the celebratory chest thumping of Schultz’s e-mail is considerably at odds with his courtroom testimony, in which described the event as a well-mannered form of collective action. Cappello ultimately did receive a copy of the e-mail from former News-Press writer Al Bonowitz, whom the News-Press had subpoenaed. Cappello was steamed because neither the Teamsters nor attorneys for the National Labor Relations Board—who are now prosecuting the News-Press for nearly 20 violations of federal labor law—had provided the requested document.

Cappello termed the e-mail “a critical piece of evidence,” and said it was one of at least six instances in which the union and the federal attorneys had failed to provide documents. Ira Gottleib, attorney for the Teamsters said that union organizer Marty Keegan had innocently deleted the document months before any subpoena had been issued, and that the Teamsters had made a “good faith effort” to produce all the documents Cappello requested. Cappello chastised the government attorneys—Brian Gee and Steven Wyllie—for not knowing about the document and not being thorough enough in the preparations. Cappello recalled that back in the days when he was still a prosecutor that he would have been far more thorough and detailed. Kocol agreed that the failure to produce documents is a serious concern, but said Cappello had not demonstrated that Keegan had deleted the e-mail either in anticipation of the subpoena or after having received the subpoena. Failing that, he said, there was no basis for sanctions.

L to R Marty Keegan, Barney McManigal, and Tom Schultz leave the U.S. Bankruptcy Court at Lunch time Wednesday.
Click to enlarge photo

Paul Wellman

L to R Marty Keegan, Barney McManigal, and Tom Schultz leave the U.S. Bankruptcy Court at Lunch time Wednesday.

Furthermore, the judge disagreed with the News-Press’s attorney over the importance of the evidence, stating, “It is not a critical piece of evidence, Mr. Cappello.” The judge did agree, however, to have Keegan placed under oath on the witness stand and have him answer questions about the document.

In the first News-Press-NLRB hearing held this January—over whether the Teamsters’ election should be recognized as valid—News-Press editors Scott Steepleton and Travis Armstrong testified how they were intimidated by the loud and boisterous manner of the newsroom employees. In that trial, Steepleton pantomimed for the judge the foot-stomping he said the protestors engaged in. Armstrong likened them to “storm troopers.” The judge in that case, William Schmidt, found their testimony singularly lacking in credibility and wrote so stingingly in his ultimate recommendation that the election results—33-to-6 in favor of the Teamsters—be certified. The News-Press appealed Schmidt’s recommendation, and two weeks ago, a three-member panel of the NLRB upheld Schmidt’s ruling. The "Rock the House" e-mail was not available during the first hearing, and had it been so, who knows what impact it might have had on the judge’s thinking.

Related Links

  • See Matt Kettmann's September 5 NLRB round-up here.
  • See Nick Welsh's September 4 NLRB round-up here.
Story Help (Click-ability)
Double-clicking on any word or phrase in this story will open a reference window with definitions and links to other reference material.

Comments

Discussion Guidelines

Whether the House indeed was rocked really is a separate issue from the metaphor in the email message by Schultz.

Are somehow the facts of history now different because a peppy email message was found later?

Would this be any different if Schultz wrote "off the hook" or "brought the house down" or whatever?

FirstDistrictStreetfighter (anonymous profile)
September 6, 2007 at 2:09 p.m. (Suggest removal)

When Barry was a prosecutor, he intentionally incited riots in IV with DA David Minier, according to Minier:

http://www.kathleensharp.com/courtney.ht...

Twenty or so law-enforcement officers suffered career-ending injuries in those riots, and a young man, Kevin Moran, who was actually trying to put out a fire in the Bank of America, lost his life when he was shot accidently by police.

The U.S. Prosecutor who was pursuing charges against folks like Cappello was fired by Richard Nixon before prosecution could begin:

http://independent.com/news/2007/mar/29/...

Any comments Barry now makes about conscientious prosecutorial behavior should be taken with a grain of salt.

sevendolphins (anonymous profile)
September 7, 2007 at 6:37 a.m. (Suggest removal)

Post a comment

Username:
Password: (Forgotten your password?)

Comment:

EVENT CALENDAR

Previous Month | Next Month

Today's Events Best Bets Submit an Event

Local Weather

Currently:
Clear Sky
Temperature:
69.1°
Wind:
3 SSW

Surf Report
  • Specials
  • InPrint
  • Top Emails
  • Blue Green Guide 2008
  • Summer Camp Guide 2008
  • Wedding Guide 2008
  • SBIFF 2008 All Access
  • 2008 Election Coverage
  • Best of Reader's Poll 2007
  • Calendar of Fundraisers
  • Local Bands
  • Kid's Mother's Day Issue
  • Made in Santa Barbara
  • Zaca Fire 2007
  • The Rockstar Who Would Save the World
  • Independent.com Heads to the Democratic National Convention
  • Fuel Price Spike Stings Area Fisherman
  • Thinking Twice About the Big Green Revolution
  • The Indy’s ‘Road to West Beach’ Brings 10 S.B. Bands One Step Closer to Stardom
  • The Plight of the Wild Mustangs
  1. Steinbeck Son Stripped of Rights
  2. How My Unquestioned Faith in the Medical Profession Went Under the Knife
  3. Shakedown From Feds Imperils Medicinal Marijuana
  4. Clawing, Chawing, Gnawing, and Pawing
  5. Santa Barbara's Soldiers Leave for Iraq
  6. Lyle Hillegas 1934-2008
  • CREATE AN ACCOUNT
  • LOG.IN
  • CONTENTS
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • ARCHIVE
  • INFO | ADVERTISING | CONTACT US
Google
 
Independent.com Web
Copyright ©2008 Santa Barbara Independent, Inc. Reproduction of material from any Independent.com pages without written permission is strictly prohibited. If you believe an Independent.com user or any material appearing on Independent.com is copyrighted material used without proper permission, please click here.
This is our Privacy Policy.