CARPINTERIA WARRIORS: When it comes to jettisoning Native American imagery at Carpinteria High School, a backlash against the backlash seems to be shaping up.
After the school board voted 3-2 to end the Indian icons but keep the team name Warriors, public opposition raged against the move. Now, as people understand the reasoning for eliminating offensive images, there’s growing support for the board majority.
On the Beat
Boardmember Leslie Deardorff, who voted in the majority, said she’s been getting far more emails recently backing her position than opposed. The controversy, which has sparked a Web recall petition drive, will be thrashed out at a school board meeting on Tuesday, May 13, at 5:30 p.m. at the Carpinteria High School gym, the largest venue available to handle the expected large crowd.
District Superintendent Paul Cordeiro feels that the board acted too hastily at the April 22 meeting, Deardorff told me, and he wants trustees to vote Tuesday to postpone until a later date their decision to eliminate the imagery.
“My main concern is keeping the community together and moving forward with all the wonderful initiatives” that have been accomplished at the school district and are in the offing, Cordeiro told me. Much has been said about Carpinteria’s so-called small-town ambience and the fact that generations of Carpinteria High graduates still live there as factors in the reaction against the image ban. But the school district has a median home value of $1.25 million and is hardly “Mayberry, U.S.A.,” according to Cordeiro.
UNION FILES NP COMPLAINT: A 2007 USC journ school grad has found himself in the middle of the Teamsters/News-Press brouhaha. Kyle Jahner, hired nearly a year ago as a sports desk temp, was laid off last week, resulting in the newsroom union filing an unfair labor practice complaint this week with the feds. Teamsters contend that the NP had a duty to bargain over the layoff because Jahner was part of the bargaining unit, even though a temp. There are an estimated six other newsroom temps.
HAPPY HORN: This ought to restore at least a touch of your faith in human nature. You’ll recall my story about how Santa Barbara Symphony trombonist Brad Close lost his $3,000 horn, then, against the odds, got it back. Brad, loading his gear into his car after a recent concert, drove off, leaving the horn and case on the sidewalk. A dishonest person might have snatched the horn and tried to make a fast buck. But along came UCSB computer technologist and research assistant Dylan Parenti. Spotting the case, Dylan waited a half-hour for an owner to claim it, then called police and said he waited another half-hour for officers to arrive. A few days later he got a letter of thanks from Close, and a $100 check. “I sent it back,” Dylan told me. “I was just glad that he got his instrument back. You can’t put a price tag on a horn and what it means to a musician.” Dylan also got a letter from the Santa Barbara Symphony offering him two tickets to Saturday’s concert at the Arlington. That he accepted. “I’ve never been [to the Symphony], and it’s something I’ve always wanted to do. And they’re playing one of my favorite pieces, Bolero.” Then there’s violinist Philippe Quint, who performed with the symphony in February and who left his borrowed $4 million Stradivarius in a Newark taxi last month. Quint played 30 minutes to cabbies at Newark Liberty International Airport this week as thanks to driver Mohamed Khalil, who returned the irreplaceable 1723 Antonio Stradivari “Ex-Keisewetter” after it was left behind in Khalil’s cab.
DISAPPOINTED WOMEN: How are Santa Barbara’s Democratic women who back Hillary Clinton for president reacting to Rep. Lois Capps’s endorsement of Barack Obama? Although Capps phoned many local activist women in advance of her announcement, many remain disappointed, one source told me. “We still love Lois,” she assured me. “We won’t abandon the party or Lois, but for right now, it is uncomfortable for a lot of us.” The women, of course, are well aware that Capps’s daughter Laura is married to Obama’s press secretary, Bill Burton, and could be headed to the White House. Capps, by the way, is one of the superdelegates who will apparently be the deciding factor in choosing the nominee at this summer’s Demo convention.
A FEEL-GOOD STORY: Nicole Cabell grew up in a low-income, working class, racially mixed family in Ventura. As a teen with African-American, Korean, and Anglo ancestry, she paid for her singing lessons by doing household chores for her teacher. Now, at 30, she’s internationally famous, having sung on the great opera stages of Europe and the U.S. and been acclaimed for her gorgeous soprano. On Sunday, Cabell will sing in the final concert of the Ventura Music Festival on the stage of her old school, Ventura High School, with tenor David Lomeli and the Festival Orchestra. Tickets and info at venturamusicfestival.org.
• Last Tuesday in Barney’s online column: Hillary-Obama ticket? (independent.com/hillaryobama). Coming Friday: You’re on candid camera at a local high-end eatery.
Related Links
Barney Brantingham can be reached at barney@independent.com or 805-965-5205. He writes online columns on Tuesdays and Fridays and a print column on Thursdays.
Double-clicking on any word or phrase in this story will open a reference window with definitions and links to other reference material.
Print friendly
E-mail story
Tip Us Off
iPod friendly
Comments
Bookmark This
Previous Month


Comments
Discussion Guidelines
carpinteria is only about 30 years behind the trend of eliminating indians as mascots. i guess life in the backwater goes slow.
Readers say: Thumbs Up: 0 of 0 • Thumbs Down: 0 of 0
cynic9 (anonymous profile)
May 9, 2008 at 5:04 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Barney,
Support for the Carpinteria Warrior Imagery Ban is growing? In fairness, you wrote this before Tuesday's board meeting.
What you may not have realized when you wrote this was that while support for the ban may have grown, support for retaining the imagery grew more, and grew faster. But it figures - the defenders are Warriors, after all.
I don't know where you stand on the issue. For me, it's not crystal clear either way. I'm slow to jump into change that I don't fully understand, but also would want to refrain form objectifying people since the wiser I become, the more I realize how much I don't know. What is clear is that the sanctimonious attitude of Salm, the misguided best intentions of the naive and immature Deardorff, and that absolutely out-of-touch mutterings of Grant have instigated unrest in the quiet town of Carpinteria.
While it was within their power to exercise more moderation, in line with what they were urged to do, they acted hastily, lacking the wisdom to make a better decision that would have better served their consituents on all sides of the issue.
But that's not what they did. Instead they ignited rage on both sides of the issue which resulted in death threats of the native american youth that submitted the original request, and caused some native Americans to lash out, connecting this event to the mass murders of the past and the ongoing "occupation."
So for me, as this continues to unfold my understanding of the actual issue and empathy for the people who support the original complaint has grown, my discontent for the irresponsible behavior of the three board members has grown more. With their action, and subsequent stubbornness, they have impaired support for the decision that they made so hastily and wrecklessly.
I was at Tuesday's board meeting. From what I saw, the board has caused the defenders of the imagery to dig their heels in for a fight. And they came out the woodwork for this meeting - approximately 1,000 in attendance of a Carpinteria school board meeting. Wow!
Unfortunately, Carpinteria is a SMALL town. After being recalled (is there any doubt?), they're going to be about as popular as Jane Fonda was, following the Vietnam War. I feel badly for them.
Readers say: Thumbs Up: 0 of 0 • Thumbs Down: 0 of 0
DefenderOfCommonSense (anonymous profile)
May 14, 2008 at 9:53 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Barney,
I just read your piece on the the Indian Icon controversy. There is more to this controversy than first meets the eye. For the moment, forget about the Icon, focus instead on a board that originally was elected because they said that they would keep our cherished Main Elementary School open. This was the primary reason they were elected. Once on the board, they set up a committee to make recommendations and then disregarded them and closed the school. This has been an ongoing problem, setting up recommendation committees and then disregarding them. The committees are made up of community members, so it is sort of like saying, the board "gets-it", but you the community "don't". A recommendation was made to close Summerland School and bus the kids to Main (about a 5 minute bus trip). This would have saved Main School. Instead, they closed Main School and are pushing a $10,000,000 plan to build a new school for 65 kids in Summerland. It is to bad that this board has chosen a path of confrontation. The Superintendent of the school district told the board that eliminating the Indian Icon would be an emotional issue and to go slow. The two board members who voted against the motion to remove the Indian Icons also told the board the same thing. What was the result, full speed ahead, remove the Icons. The first step in conflict resolution is to listen to the other side and understand it enough to be able to restate the other sides objections. This reassures the other side that you understand their point of view and leads to compromise. Failure to follow this basic step leads to polarization and the building of stone walls. I know that Salm, Deardorf and Grant have the community interest at heart (from their point of view) and that they are honorable ladies, but when you fail to include the community in decision process, you build stone walls. It is to bad that Amrita could not have used some of her RamaKrishna philosphy to pull down the walls instead of being combative and building them up. It is unfortunate, because in this case, wall building leads to recall and none of these ladies will ever be elected again to any general office or board in carpinteria.
Readers say: Thumbs Up: 0 of 0 • Thumbs Down: 0 of 0
carpresident (anonymous profile)
May 23, 2008 at 12:34 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Post a comment