Arthur von Wiesenberger and Wendy McCaw

Arthur von Wiesenberger and Wendy McCaw

News-Press Loses SLAPP Suit

The Santa Barbara News-Press and its owner, Wendy McCaw, lost a legal tussle over the First Amendment last week in Orange County, where a Superior Court judge affirmed that none of the 33 alleged libelous statements contained in Susan Paterno’s December 2006 American Journalism Review article “Santa Barbara Smackdown” were provably false.

Without providing evidence of the statements’ falsehood, the judge ruled that no malice could be established and barred News-Press attorneys from deposing Paterno, a journalism instructor at Chapman University in Orange, California. News-Press attorneys had argued they could expose Paterno’s malice by showing what she did not include.

Paterno claimed she was rebuffed in efforts to get management’s side of the story to the extent that she received letters from McCaw’s legal team threatening her with harassment if she did not back off. Furthermore, Paterno denied ever being asked to submit her question in writing, as has been reported.

In response to McCaw’s libel action, Paterno and American Journalism Review filed an Anti-SLAPP (Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation) suit, claiming McCaw was abusing the legal process to silence critics. Last week’s action sets the stage for the final reckoning-scheduled now for October 29-at which McCaw and the News-Press will be ordered to pay the legal costs Paterno incurred defending herself.

Given that Paterno snagged the legal talents of Chuck Tobin, a nationally known First Amendment specialist out of Washington, D.C., those costs could be substantial. A written request for comment to attorney Barry Cappello, now representing McCaw’s dispute with Paterno and American Journalism Review, went unanswered.

To submit a comment on this article, email or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email

event calendar sponsored by:

Rescue Mission Plans Annual Feast and Giveaway

December 20 event celebrates the holidays and provides warm clothing.

Volunteers Canvas Montecito’s ‘Red Zones’

Door-to-door outreach delivers storm-readiness info.

Sometime S.B. Resident Ryan Zinke to Step Down

All roads to lead to Santa Barbara — even Trump’s.

Highway Patrol Bears Gifts to Unity Shoppe

Officers collect and deliver donated children's toys to support service.

Adam Brothers Farm Identified in E. Coli Outbreak

Santa Maria farm recalls romaine and additional produce.