WEATHER »

Paul Wellman

Mize Trial Close to Finish

Jury to Decide What is Truth Amongst Conflicting Testimonies


The prosecution’s case against the four people alleged to be responsible for the death of 16-year-old Lorenzo Carachure in July 2007 is beginning to wind down, which begs the question: Has prosecutor Hans Almgren proven his case?

Jurors have heard testimony that the four defendants — Ruben Mize, Raul Diaz, Bryan Medinilla, and Ricardo Nava, all facing murder charges — traveled over to the Westside that night. They’ve listened to an audiotape on which Mize tells his cousin, who was working as a confidential informant, that he “stuck” Carachure in the neck, and they’ve heard statements from other people who talked to other defendants about their involvement.

Detective Gary Siegel
Click to enlarge photo

Paul Wellman

Detective Gary Siegel

But they’ve also heard conflicting testimony. Some people on the stand said there were five Eastsiders, others said as many as eight. Varying testimony has described weapons such as knives, sticks, a corkscrew, and even a curling iron. Some witnesses claimed there were three people stabbing the victim, while some reported there were only one or two stabbing him in the neck. Some have said the Eastsiders attacked the Westsiders, some say both sides held their ground. The getaway vehicle was a pickup truck, according to some witnesses, while others said it was an SUV. And, some of the key testimony is coming from witnesses who have worked out plea deals with Almgren in their own criminal cases, either related to this incident or otherwise.

So it remains to be seen how these discrepancies play out among the 12 members of the jury. Certain inconsistencies are surely the result of a dark street, a series of events that unfolded quickly, and a three-year-old case. It will be up to the jury to decide what is the truth.

To submit a comment on this article, email letters@independent.com or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email tips@independent.com.



event calendar sponsored by:

Senior Fair Hosts the ‘Young at Heart’

The Senior Fair brought together more than 25 organizations to match needs with services.

City College Ranked #1 by Value Colleges

High graduation rate, community service, and online degree programs made SBCC a 'flawless investment.'

News Commentary: Ribbon Cutting Is Not As Easy As It Looks

Grand opening for new Eastside bridge conveys a tingle of progress.

Santa Barbara Rental Prices Have Skyrocketed Over the Last Five Years

The average rent for a South Coast studio is $1,553.

Trio Stops the Show at Board of Education

More than a dozen appeal to Santa Barbara Unified School District to maintain music classes and programs.