A Bible in Every Hotel Room—or Not
Man Takes Umbrage, Hotel Removes Offending Items
Thursday, June 24, 2010
GIDEONS’ BIBLE: I’ve been in hotel rooms all over the world and seldom peered into a bedside table drawer unless it was to look for a phone book or bottle opener. What I usually found, at least in the U.S., were Bibles. After a visitor named Diego Costa wrote me, taking great offense at finding a Bible in a Santa Barbara motel, I learned that Gideons International has distributed 1.5 billion copies of “the good book,” mostly in hotel and motel rooms, in 80 languages and 190 countries, since 1908.
Barney Brantingham
Costa, who describes himself as a PhD researcher in cinematic arts at USC, said, “When I decided to spend my birthday in Santa Barbara (I turned 30! In L.A. years, which is where I live, that is about 50, and in gay years, it’s probably 80) with my boyfriend, I did not know I’d start changing the world one hotel at a time.
“Every time my boyfriend and I go on vacation the ‘bed’ seems to be an issue. In most countries, the hotel assumes we want two beds because we are two males. This causes an awkward situation, for them at least, when we get to the room and realize it has two beds.
“Out of principle I always ask for a room with just one bed, even if it’s smaller—to go against the hotel’s assumption that everyone is heterosexual.
“This time … there was no bed issue, but there was a bible in the bedside table drawer in the room. As a non-straight person, I feel that is as offensive as keeping a copy of Mein Kampf in a room where a Jewish couple checks into.
“I object because the bible has been used, historically, as an exclusionary tool. As a gay man, specifically, the bible symbolizes a history of violence and hatred against people ‘like me.’ With Prop. 8 being taken up by the courts right now, this is the perfect zeitgeist to revisit this ‘standard procedure’ of leaving bibles in hotel rooms along with the heterosexist assumptions inherent to that practice.
“When you leave a bible in a room for someone who’s paying a lot of money to be there, you assume the guest will like that object, perhaps read it or, at least, take solace in the knowledge of its presence.
“But I am paying just as much money as the [presumed Christian] hetero couple who might stay in the room … The question should be, ‘Why have a bible in a hotel room?’ not, ‘Why not have a bible in a hotel room?’”
“Out of principle I always ask for a room with just one bed, even if it’s smaller—to go against the hotel’s assumption that everyone is heterosexual.”
As Costa checked out, he told the front desk person about his concern. It would be passed on to the supervisor, he was told. “I didn’t think anything would happen,” Costa said, “but less than one hour after I left the hotel, the concierge called my cell to let me know that was just a standard practice for hotels from the 19th century and that since nobody had ever complained about the bible, they kept them in each room through the years.
“He also told me they would be taking every single bible out of every single room not only from the hotel I stayed in but from other hotels they owned in the area.”
Who knows, it could catch on. If you think Costa’s going too far, remember the old saying that racism and intolerance reach a peak at 11 a.m. on Sundays.
OH THAT EMAIL: Josh Lynn’s fate as chief south country trial deputy at the District Attorney’s Office was sealed when he became a “renegade,” according to a source close to the DA’s office. When Lynn, who lost the DA’s race to fellow prosecutor Joyce Dudley, sent a mass county email to the staff falsely claiming to have been “suspended,” and went to the news media trashing Dudley and acting DA Ann Bramsen, the latter had no alternative but to fire him, my source said. Dudley was sworn into office Tuesday, June 22, to cheers. Lynn has kept a low profile, and it’s widely believed that he had no intention of serving under the command of Dudley after they’d tangled with one another so bitterly during the campaign.
LAKE LAS VEGAS: Out driving one day, Sue and I discovered this desert oasis a half-hour from Sin City, not realizing that it was built by a Santa Barbaran. The 3,600-acre Lake Las Vegas resort, a pretend Italian village on a manmade lake, was the brainchild of Ron Boeddeker. Alas, the $4 billion project, hit by the recession, fell into bankruptcy two years ago. Santa Barbara-born Boeddeker died here Saturday, June 19, at 71.
HOT AND COLD: Described as “Agatha Christie meets 42nd Street,” Curtains is a Broadway song-dance-mystery show that’s full of brash energy and clever lyrics. The show is hot, but be sure to dress warmly when you take in the PCPA Theaterfest show at Solvang’s open-air Festival Theater. I got a kick out of Ethel Merman-esque Kitty Balay playing the brassy producer, and Erik Stein as the flamboyant English director.
Related Links
Comments
In regards to "OH THAT EMAIL" - my sentiments exactly.
magnoliaswingset (anonymous profile)
June 23, 2010 at 2:33 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Who's paying you to be Dudley's PR man, Barney?
You now have totally lost the respect of at least one local reader.
Lars (anonymous profile)
June 23, 2010 at 10:52 p.m. (Suggest removal)
It's totally insane that a so-called reporter (Barney) claims that Lynn went to "the news media trashing Dudley and acting DA Ann Bramsen."
What are you talking about? He didn't "TRASH" either one of them. He simply stated that it appeared he was being fired.
AREN'T REPORTERS SUPPOSED TO PROVIDE SOME SHREAD OF EVIDENCE BEFORE MAKING SUCH SERIOUS CLAIMS???
Your reporting is so biased at this point, it STINKS!
Lars (anonymous profile)
June 23, 2010 at 11:08 p.m. (Suggest removal)
This isn't a news story -- it's a column, written by columnist Barney Brantingham. On the Beat is clearly labeled as a column.
Moonrunner (anonymous profile)
June 24, 2010 at 9:17 a.m. (Suggest removal)
LMAO Barney, are you actually serious? ... an email? I have seen that email and it is not any reason for Dudley's immature emotional tyriad.
Good Grief, an email is the basis to fire a seasonaed prosecutor.
LMAOOOO
detokevilla (anonymous profile)
June 24, 2010 at 11:35 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Lars, apparently you don't know the difference between a "beat reporter" and a "columnist". The first reports events and occasions supposedly without "bias", the second is written by a "columnist" that can put his/her slant/bias on a column as he/she sees fit, most people accept this when reading a column. If you don't like Barney's slant, then don't read his column.
chuckUfarley (anonymous profile)
June 24, 2010 at 2:05 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Costa is WAY off base.
First, he mixes his frustration regarding bed arrangements with the Gideon bible. These are two totally separate issues and he'd be well advised to heed the distinction.
Regarding the bible, his assertion that, "When you leave a bible in a room for someone who's paying a lot of money to be there, you assume the guest will like that object, perhaps read it or, at least, take solace in the knowledge of its presence." is just a load of hooey. No such assumption is made at all.
Hey Costa, if you don't like the bible, don't read it. A private company has every right to allow the Gideons to put bibles in motel rooms. Or the Koran. Or the Kama Sutra, for that matter. Sheesh, get over yourself.
And that phone call from the concierge (if it was really him/her) is completely bogus. The Gideons have NOT been putting bibles in hotel rooms from the 19th century. And they won't be removing the bibles from the rooms. They only told you that to cool your jets. Wanna test this? Come back in 3 months and I guarantee you that the bible will still be there.
Lest you think I'm a Gideon, I assure you that I'm an atheist who thinks the bible is also a bunch of hooey. But I support the notion that private companies can enact whatever policies they want within the law...and that includes the utterly stupid policy of acquiescing to the darn Gideons.
SezMe (anonymous profile)
June 25, 2010 at 1:45 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Costa just has a chip on his shoulder. Like HE is the only person in the world that Bible was there for? He's renting a furnished room! Others who rent it may appreciate that Bible. Over many centuries, people who have read the Bible have been inspired, saved from suicide, enjoyed love poetry, war stories, wondered about life, and yes, even found God. It addresses many needs for many people. Just because Costa hates it is no sign other renters of the room do.
My grandmother, wise woman, used to say, "if you have insomnia, just start reading your Bible and the Devil will put you to sleep!" Great literature and a soporific. And the guy's protesting :)
gleetagal (anonymous profile)
June 25, 2010 at 9:27 a.m. (Suggest removal)
I enjoy putting my fine-point black ink pen in the noses of Gideon bibles while whistling:
Rocky Raccoon / Checked into his room / Only to find / Funny stick figure pictures drawn atop the most salacious, silly, and mistranslated conscripted passages from the symbolic bastion of that most dangerous weapon in the arsenal of Mankind: religion.
Try it. It's fun!
Draxor (anonymous profile)
June 25, 2010 at 10:43 a.m. (Suggest removal)
C'mon, Draxor, tell us how you REALLY feel. :-)
SezMe (anonymous profile)
June 25, 2010 at 3:01 p.m. (Suggest removal)
I'm sure Barney will have many sleepless nights over losing the respect of someone like Lars.
truth_machine (anonymous profile)
June 25, 2010 at 3:08 p.m. (Suggest removal)
I was a little confused by Barney's ending statement in his short article, A Bible In Every Hotel Room-Or Not. Who was he talking about when he said that racism and intolerance reach a peak at 11:00 a.m. on Sunday? Gideon? Costa? The Hotel staff or owners? If Mr. Brantingtham was talking about Costa's egocentric and vaguely bilious intolerance then he was right on the money, if not, if he was somehow implying that Christians or Bible manufacturers or hotel chains are racist and intolerant because they leave Bibles in hotel rooms, then, apparently, our erstwhile columnist has sustained a blow to the head recently and should seek medical attention.
I've got a feeling Mr. Costa rushes to investigate that drawer every time he checks into a hotel and always will, despite taking "great offense' at what he finds there. This is called "whining". But he is not satisfied with an ordinary whine, no, he attempts to supplement his Bible-whine by complaining about beds too, beds that, in his own words, come in twos "in most countries in the world," A fact that, by it's ubiquitous nature, would seem to overrule the writers rather narrow and self-interested opinions.
If, as Costa says, his and his boyfriends quirks and furniture constraints cause the hotel staff "an awkward situation" then why do they push the issue? As long as they're not being charged for the extra bed, which I'm sure they are not, what's the point? Well, I think we know the answer to that question.
By the letter-writers level of indignation one would think the hotel chain was leaving turds in the drawer when in fact it's just a book, a book he doesn't even have to read. Besides, by his standards, since I happen to think television is a blight on humanity, and since many hotels make violent movies and other injurious forms of entertainment available on their televisions, I should be able to march down to the office and demand they remove all their television sets... right Costa?
shibboleth (Wayne Gilbert Myers)
June 26, 2010 at 2:51 a.m. (Suggest removal)
shibboleth, you entirely missed the point of Barney's closing line. It's an old saying, not something Barney made up to apply to any of the people in the current story.
In olden days, church service was at 11 am on Sunday morning. At that hour, whites would go to their church and blacks to theirs. Period. The church was (and still is) one of the most racially segregated institutions in America.
Consider current day Santa Barbara and you'll notice the situation is not a whole lot different. Blacks, Whites, and Latinos have, to a very large extent, their own churches. With a more diverse America, the trend is even more pronounced. The greeks have their own place, the Asians likewise, and so on.
So, like all bromides, it is a stereotype that contains a germ of truth. 11 am on Sunday morning is the zenith of racism and intolerance in America.
SezMe (anonymous profile)
June 26, 2010 at 12:42 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Dear Mr. Brantingham,
We are so disappointed at the mean-spirited way you have reported the outrageous actions of the D.A.'s office against Josh Lynn. It really surprised me that you would not express some respect or gratitude for the dedicated service he gave our city; I previously thought you were a more dignified resident here. With this kind of experience, why would anyone want to run for public office in our city (and look who we do get!)?? You have diminished your own reputation by supporting these truly disgraceful actions.
SanRoqueMom (anonymous profile)
June 28, 2010 at 2:33 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Worthy of death in Old and New Testaments, Diego. Did Hitler go that far in Mein Kampf?
But you should welcome those Bibles as opportunities, IMO. Google a list of Bible contradictions, print it, and annotate those Gideon's Bibles in red ink. It will help to know abbreviations, for example, Gen 7:2 vs Gen 7:8 (the ancient scribes faithfully retained a lot of contradictory sources).
Let the Bible debunk itself, rather than reminding literalists that you're an inessential abomination in the Big Book of Trooth.
Adonis_Tate (anonymous profile)
June 29, 2010 at 6:05 p.m. (Suggest removal)
"... racism and intolerance reach a peak at 11 a.m. on Sundays."
Intolerance is more reliably found in this column, not limited to a day or hour.
It's bias against faith, or more accurately, a smug condescension towards PEOPLE of faith, because, Barney, YOU just called whites, blacks, and hispanics who go to church all racist and intolerant.
ahem (anonymous profile)
July 5, 2010 at 8:24 p.m. (Suggest removal)