Family’s Dream Ends with a Nightmare
They Came Here with Nothing but Togetherness
Thursday, September 2, 2010
AND SUDDEN DEATH: And so the immigrant family is homeward bound to Oaxaca, their dreams for a better life having ended with sudden death in Santa Barbara.
Leon Leonel, 23, and his wife, Lorena Guadalupe-Tellez Pacheco, 27, struggled, as immigrants to the New World have for thousands of years, starting with those who crossed the Bering Straits from Asia.
Following 1492, a mass exodus from Europe to America began, and the immigrants have kept on coming ever since. My ancestors from England, my wife’s from Italy and Canada, my former wife’s from Spain and Panama.
Barney Brantingham
Bodies of Leon, Lorena, and her eight-year-old son, Jaciel, killed when a brakeless gravel truck crushed their modest cottage behind the Hope Ranch Inn on August 24, are on their way back to be buried in one of Mexico’s southernmost and poorest regions, Oaxaca.
What hardships they endured during their trek here, no one that I talked to in the family would spell out. “It’s a life-or-death situation to come here,” said John Paul Guizar, one of the inn managers. “It’s an ugly, risky journey.” You risk robbery and murder on your way north to the border and death in the broiling deserts on this side. Leon’s 20-year-old brother, Juventino, who had left the house earlier that morning, said only, “It’s the way Mexicans come here. Through hardship.”
Poverty and hopelessness back home drove them on despite the risks. Desperate times call for desperate measures. Living for a time in Los Angeles, they decided to push on: “Looking for better opportunities, a better life in Santa Barbara,” Juventino told me.
This meant sharing a cramped Eastside house — then a wonderful opportunity came along, a cottage of their own behind the Hope Ranch Inn and benevolent landlords, managers Nancy Schliemann and her husband, John Paul.
“They came with nothing,” Nancy said. “They made it beautiful.” Prior tenants, locals with college degrees, had turned it into, in Nancy’s words, “a pig-sty.” Nancy and John Paul provided a bed, couch, and other necessities. The family paid the rent on time, every month. “They wanted a white picket fence, and we had one made,” John Paul told me. “One thing they had: togetherness.”
Santa Barbara also meant the warm arms of Franklin School, where Jaciel was loved. Jaciel, who started third grade the day before, was crazy for computers. Lorena made sure he got to school every day, and she never missed a field trip. That same morning she was to start a new job as a nanny. Leon and Juventino worked in a popular downtown restaurant.
Even as the Hope Ranch Inn was sponsoring a benefit BBQ last Friday to raise funds to send the bodies home, some not present were sneering: “Mexicans. Illegals. Why don’t they work in their own country?” There is no work, of course.
True, they were doubtlessly without immigration papers. I am not in favor of illegal immigration. But there’s particular resentment against immigrants without papers who arrive from south of the border, less toward those from Asia and Europe. And the immigration issue has been taken up by politicians using it as a convenient issue without offering a workable solution. In the eyes of some, the father, mother, and child buried in gravel when the big rig slammed into their home were nothing more than “Mexican illegals.”
Nancy sees it differently, with compassion. “They just wanted a better life for their boy, a little boy with big eyes, eager to learn. It was the American dream. They were very humble people. She was a devoted mother.” It’s a new heartache for Nancy, memories returning of her own young son killed in an accident a few years ago. The prejudice she hears is painful. “You can’t judge people by the color of their skin.” But she was heartened by the line of people awaiting their turn to donate. “The community has come out in force. Santa Barbara cares.”
Not everyone is anxious for an end to people from Mexico and Central America crossing the border and providing low-wage workers. Some years ago, when a crackdown at the California border temporarily slowed the flow, San Joaquin ranchers complained in the Los Angeles Times that they weren’t getting their “fair share” of illegal field workers.
People at the barbecue lined up patiently for dinners of chicken, tri-tip, beans, bread, and dessert. For many, the five-dollar price was all they could afford. Others stuffed $100 bills into the jar. Albertsons markets, where Nancy works, donated all the food, the Elks Club donated the grill, Rudy’s restaurant provided paper plates and other items, and State Street Hospitality, owner of the inn, allowed the victims’ family to stay there without charge.
South Coast Albertsons store managers manned the food preparation table, including area vice president Jacque Morris. Also busy helping with dinners was Erasmo Zapien, who’d leaped for his life when the truck came roaring down.
Newly elected DA Joyce Dudley was there and told me that her office was making a careful investigation of the tragedy.
A shrine of flowers rested against the fence in front of the ruined house, crushed like a family’s shattered dreams.
Related Links
Barney Brantingham can be reached at barney@independent.com or 805-965-5205. He writes online columns throughout the week and a print column on Thursdays.
Comments
This hardship is why I don't support illegal immigration. No one should risk life and limb to come here and work low paying jobs. Besides the fundraisers, what else do they have? What will the surviving son do? I can't see how people think that people leave their hometown to a hostile land for welfare benefits. It happens like that, but nobody comes here with that idea.
AZ2SB (anonymous profile)
September 3, 2010 at 8:45 a.m. (Suggest removal)
This was a beautifully done article, Barney. I am so glad that so many people in Santa Barbara came out to celebrate these lives and mourn their tragic deaths.
It is unfortunate that the comments have above have to be so cruel.
bajamama (anonymous profile)
September 3, 2010 at 12:36 p.m. (Suggest removal)
I apoligize if it sounded cruel, I wasn't trying to. It is just that I have seen so many of these incidents and it is terrible that people come here with hope and leave with only a casket.
AZ2SB (anonymous profile)
September 3, 2010 at 1:11 p.m. (Suggest removal)
I didn't realize this had become political football for race politics; I thought we were simply outraged that innocent people were killed by a truck driver with numerous previous traffic violations.
billclausen (anonymous profile)
September 4, 2010 at 3:14 p.m. (Suggest removal)
By the way Barney, who were the people sneering about their residential status and how were those comments dealt with? Awaiting an answer. -Bill-
billclausen (anonymous profile)
September 4, 2010 at 3:17 p.m. (Suggest removal)
"who were the people sneering"
They were made of straw.
As an immigration restrictionist myself (who is a legal immigrant, unlike Barney) I am simply horrified and saddened by the fate of this family.
Barney is himself exploiting this story to assuage his WASP guilt by bashing restrictionists in an extremely inappropriate manner that takes the focus away from a horrific and avoidable accident.
revisionist (anonymous profile)
September 5, 2010 at 7:02 a.m. (Suggest removal)
As I say: I'm interested to hear who the people are Barney mentions and what he (or those who told him about these people) did to deal with them.
I remember how in the death of Mata Ocampo--the woman killed by a drunk driver--a blogger decided to make it into a racial issue.
(http://www.independent.com/news/2009/...)
billclausen (anonymous profile)
September 5, 2010 at 3:23 p.m. (Suggest removal)
"Macrina" Ocampo. As I say, we're not allowed to be outraged about drinking and driving or about owner-operators of trucks with a recent history of numerous violations without having the essence of the story twisted around.
billclausen (anonymous profile)
September 5, 2010 at 3:26 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Revisionist I have a question: How is Barney here illegally?
billclausen (anonymous profile)
September 5, 2010 at 3:28 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Meant to say I'm an immigrant unlike Barney. But I'll show him my papers if he shows me his.
revisionist (anonymous profile)
September 5, 2010 at 5:55 p.m. (Suggest removal)
"True, they were doubtlessly without immigration papers. "
A generalization without support. I guess certain journalists accepted by the "progressive" left can get away with such comments without criticism of being racist.
Tenure alone should not equal credibility.
billclausen (anonymous profile)
September 7, 2010 at 3:55 p.m. (Suggest removal)
As usual, Barney does not provide answers to the hoi polloi such as ourselves.
billclausen (anonymous profile)
September 7, 2010 at 3:58 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Isn't it enough that this happened and three people are dead? Does this HAVE to become yet ANOTHER defense of illegal immigration?
I wonder how much Barney or anyone else in the local media would have cared if this were an elderly couple? Or a couple of college kids?
It would have been a blip on the news for a day or two and would have been worked as much as possible by the "get trucks off the 154" crowd, then it would have been off the radar, replaced by something more exciting.
What Barney refuses to see is that the illegal immigration problem is a literal tsunami if humanity pouring over the SOUTHERN border. They aren't coming from Canada, or Germany, or Japan. The living conditions in Canada, Germany and Japan are pretty nice. People stay in those places, as a rule, or emigrate legally and go through proper channels.
But the living conditions south of the US border are dreadful.
So, like it or not, and no matter how much Barney or anyone else wants to force a round peg into a square hole, the southern border is where the mass bulk of illegal entrants are coming from.
Nobody is going to leave their home, family, friends, culture, language etc and risk life and limb to spend a fortune to then sneak into another country, their first act being to break that country's laws of entry unless their living conditions are horrid at home.
Mexico needs to make life for its own people better. We are not the Mexican government's ATM machine. We are not responsible for the conditions down there. The sooner the Mexican government is forced to deal with their own country's conditions, and to provide for its own people, the better off THEY will be.
And WE won't still be having this discussion.
Holly (anonymous profile)
September 8, 2010 at 9 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Amen.
brimo7272 (anonymous profile)
September 14, 2010 at 2:56 p.m. (Suggest removal)