Kate Bosworth and James Marsden as Amy and David Sumner in the 2011 version of <em>Straw Dogs</em>.

Kate Bosworth and James Marsden as Amy and David Sumner in the 2011 version of Straw Dogs.

Straw Dogs

James Marsden, Kate Bosworth, and James Woods star in a film based on the screenplay by Sam Peckinpah and David Zelag Goodman and written and directed by Rod Lurie.

In 1971, when the original Straw Dogs rudely debuted, the dominant mood in American arts and letters was left-leaning and anti-war. To many reviewers, Sam Peckinpah’s film seemed reactionary, arguing that Earthly peace and love were impossible, and accentuating the proposition by setting up a violent assault on a young couple in the merry ole English countryside. Back then, when right-wingers wanted to “prove” the futility of pacifism, they often fell back on visceral arguments like, “What would you do if the Red Chinese invaded us and raped your girlfriend?” Peckinpah’s film gave us invasion, rape, and, to turn the screw, a dewy-eyed academic victim (Dustin Hoffman, in a role he claims to regret) who turns vengeful, of course. Peckinpah might have been a crypto-Nazi, but he knew how to make movies. And even if you despised the message, it was hard to argue with his film, which stated that, then and now, the world is full of violence.

But Rod Lurie is no Sam Peckinpah, and in 2011, this same story without the hippie idealism surrounding it just looks stupid. Doubtless, the filmmakers knew this from the start, as they desperately try to make the plot make sense by over-motivating everything. The events leading up to a bloody siege on the home of the couple (played by James Marsden and Kate Bosworth) include plot points like a hung cat and a mentally challenged hulk (think Lennie in Of Mice and Men); it’s stuff that seemed thematic in the original, but here just feels like overkill. In turn, Lurie fails to connect these ham-fisted attacks logically; he just throws everything out, while Marsden, without Hoffman’s pacifist halo, comes across more dumb than sacrificial.

Still, Lurie’s Dogs has undeniable moments. Cross-cutting horrors — like a rape played out while the victim’s hubby shoots his first deer — are obvious but engage us breathlessly. Nonetheless, the bloody conclusion will likely make you laugh. There’s a bear trap involved, and right about the time it snaps, it already seems overdue, much like the film’s sad conclusion that violence prevails. Giving into that makes straw dogs of us all.

For showtimes, check the Independent's movie listings, here.

To submit a comment on this article, email or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email

event calendar sponsored by:

Biggest Storm Since 1/9 Approaching Santa Barbara

The storm system brings increased threat of flash floods and debris flows.

Jack Johnson Tours Montecito Disaster Area Ahead of Benefit Concert

Jack and Kim Johnson met with Bucket Brigade leaders to see the destruction firsthand.

Iron Chef Caused State Street Pedestrian Death

Famous Chef Larry Forgione charged with misdemeanor for driving into Gilbert Ramirez on February 24.

Lavagnino’s Sudden Victory

5th District supervisor a shoo-in as filing window closes; Gregg Hart also unopposed for 2nd District.

One Half of Old Town Streets to Get Sidewalks

Walkways planned for one side of Goleta neighborhood streets; parking, lighting talks at community meeting March 22.