Water v. Oil

Wednesday, December 5, 2012
Article Tools
Print friendly
E-mail story
Tip Us Off
iPod friendly
Share Article

Mark Kram’s letter to the editor (“Fracking Water“) opens an interesting Pandora’s box. Having worked in the oil patch, one realizes it is very much a dog-eat-dog (and anyone else standing around) business. Mark mentions the water used in fracking. That, for all practical purposes, is lost water, it does not come back. But that is just a fraction of the water used.

When looking for oil, there is an enormous demand for water and, interestingly enough, this is seldom discussed. Another big user of water that does not return is the high-quality water needed for thermally enhanced oil recovery (TEOR). This is through the injection of steam into the formation to make the oil less viscous and more easily pumped.

Thus, as we shun the alternative sources of renewable energy, we really shoot ourselves in the foot because we are using up a resource that we can not live with out: water. Large areas of this country are living on borrowed time. These are communities relying on underlying fossil aquifers and these are not small communities but major portions of this nation. These fossil aquifers were put in place long ago by systems that no longer exist, like the melt water from giant glaciers that moved down across what is now the continental United States long ago, and then receded when the ice age abated. Once that water is pumped out, that’s the end of it, and the overlying very large dependent populations will be competing for other sources.

The climate experts are predicting a return to dust-bowl days with major dust storms. These dry areas will expand as the underlying aquifers are depleted and the overlying ag land dries out. Many of these areas are so over-tilled that the soil fails to clump and thus is even more prone to blow away as it dries out. The only thing holding the soil down in many areas is irrigation water.

These are also often lands that have had years of sewage sludge applied as a form of fertilizer. Sewage sludge is the solids left over when the water is removed from sewage. In big cities with lots of polluting industry, industry dumps its waste to the sewer and these industrial wastes end up in the sewage sludge. As the farms dry down, this soil contaminated with years of sewage sludge will start to blow about. Sewer plants are also one of the prime generators of antibiotic resistant pathogens and these pathogens and their hard-to-destroy genes end up in the sludge.

A good example is Adenovirus-C, which is a lung pathogen found in about 78 percent of the sewage sludge. The problem is that regulatory agencies don’t use that pathogen as an indicator of pollution but rather Adenovirus-F, which is found at a rate of 0.7% of samples. Thus, while highly infective, the sewage sludge gets a passing grade because the regulators use the wrong indicators. Regional dust storms are predicted to increase as climate change takes effect. The lung damage from these dust storms will, because of entrained pathogens from land-applied sewage sludge, see vast populations affected by antibiotic resistant pathogens and lung disease that will be hard to treat, if treatable at all.

These will be some of the costs associated when we put alternative energy sources on the back burner and rely on extracting fossil fuels without regard to associated impacts. As Mark says, the “unintended consequences will rule the day.”

Dr. Edo McGowan specializes in medical geo-hydrology.


Independent Discussion Guidelines

Ladies and gentlemen, the "Doom and Gloomers" are at it again. The past hundred years (and much farther back) have been filled with thousands upon thousands of doom and gloom predictions about the end of this and the end of that. *which never materialized*, mostly due to Human (not animals and trees and wild nature, but mankind) innovating.

90% of fresh water from rain and snow melt ends up in a lake or an ocean, *and evaporates* into .... where?.... a *rain cloud* that then rains down fresh water again.

97% of the moisture responsible rain cloud formation comes from the ocean - even in the middle of the U.S.... the moisture is in non-rain clouds that travel and form and un-form for hundreds and even thousands of miles until they form rainclouds and dispense fresh water.

Guess what? The Ocean is *full* of water to keep this cycle going.

Good grief!
Again, we have to wonder what the author's real motivation all about? Is it normal doom-and-gloomer hand wringing or is it anti-oil, anti-capitalism, anti-modern carbon based economy/civilizaton - or a toxic mix of both.

willy88 (anonymous profile)
December 6, 2012 at 3:52 p.m. (Suggest removal)

When they pollute your backyard, you will believe
.....Waiting for all the non-truth, anti fact, and paid pro oil/business/slavery types to spew by product about how we don't understand anything and are to dumb to contemplate the destruction of the planet by the oil industry, psych....

spacey (anonymous profile)
December 6, 2012 at 4:17 p.m. (Suggest removal)

event calendar sponsored by: