WEATHER »

Jury Awards Homeowners $300,000 After City Abandons Road


Although a Santa Barbara jury awarded two property owners a combined $311,000 last week because Santa Barbara City Hall had abandoned the road — Ealand Place — leading to their homes, the attorney representing the victorious parties said he was “very, very disappointed” with the verdict and has vowed to appeal. Attorney Joe Liebman said the jury ignored evidence that the loss of road access cost his clients $750,000 in diminished property value. “Imagine the road to your house has just disappeared over night and the closest you can get to your house is now 150 feet away down a very steep deteriorated dirt path,” Liebman said.

City attorney Steve Wiley said the council abandoned the road because the ground underneath was geologically unstable, like many properties near Conejo Road, and that it would cost City Hall $4.5 million to repair. Those repairs, he added, might last only two years given how fast the earth is sliding. He expressed great relief that verdict was not larger.

Liebman said the city’s expert witness provided no estimate as to loss of property value. The jury, he said, was incorrectly given permission by the judge to ignore his expert witness. Liebman said he will ask Judge Thomas Anderle to reconsider, after-the-fact, his instructions to the jurors allowing them to decide for themselves what the loss of value was. Should Anderle decline, Liebman said, he’d file an appeal.

Liebman’s clients have lived in the mudslide-prone area since well before the 1980s, when City Hall put property owners on notice the terrain was too unstable for further development.

To submit a comment on this article, email letters@independent.com or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email tips@independent.com.



event calendar sponsored by:

Mental Health Experts Consider More Psychiatric Beds

Hospital leaders are in talks with county Behavioral Wellness and Sheriff's Office.

Report on Disasters Praised, Criticized

A representative with Montecito's volunteer responders found the report lacking.

Bellosguardo Fundraiser Draws Big Donors and Heavy Criticism

The nonprofit foundation, set up to fulfill Huguette Clark's legacy, also faces a legal challenge.

Arts and Honors Scholarship Deadlines Approach

High school seniors can now apply to S.B. Scholarship Foundation for financial awards.

UCSB Suspension for Sexual Assault Overturned

The accused student was “denied a fair hearing.”