WEATHER »

Law of Nations Get-Around


According to the Associated Press (Jan. 4, 2013) President Obama has taken time out from his island vacation to issue the following legal opinion:

“Decisions regarding the disposition of detaineees captured on foreign battlefields have traditionally been based on the judgment of experienced military commanders and national security professionals without unwarranted interference by members of Congress.” Clearly the tradition he is invoking here is not the one established by the Constitution but rather by our government’s recent tendency to ignore that document in order to wage  it’s no-holds-barred war on terrorism. Article I gives to Congress alone the power “ To define and punish Piracies and Felonies committed on the high Seas, and offenses against the Law of Nations; and, “To declare war, grant letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning captures on Land and Water.”

By not asking Congress for a Declaration of War, President Bush hoped to  remove suspected terrorists from the shelter of the Geneva Convention, the  “Law of Nations” which protects prisoners of war  from being tortured. While President Obama has restored the conventional protections against torture, the prisoners at Guantanamo remain outside the guarantees of the Constitution, which include Habeus Corpus and the right to a fair trial. Here it is worth noting that, like pirates, terrorists are non-state actors, whose disposition the Constitution assigns to Congress (that bunch of amateurs)  and not to the president, a group of generals, or, heaven forfend, “national security professionals.”

The Constitution is a document that presidents and members of Congress have both sworn to uphold. Had, following 9/11, they done so, the problem of how to close the book on Guantanamo would have been solved beforehand by not opening this haven from the law in the first place. It seems clear that the Articles of the Constitution will just be words on paper, unless we the people start demanding that our elected representatives exercise and not give away in a panic the power these words give to them.

To submit a comment on this article, email letters@independent.com or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email tips@independent.com.



event calendar sponsored by:

City Closes In on New Police Station Location

Santa Barbara's Saturday Farmers Market may lose its 35-year site.

Homeless Could Get ‘Tiny Box’ Homes Downtown

Neighbors complain as City Hall fast-tracks grant application.

Ethnic Studies to Become Graduation Requirement

School board votes unanimously for 2023 start date.

School Shooting Threat to Santa Maria Schools Made via Facebook

Further investigation revealed that suspect did not have access to firearms.

Celebration of Life Ceremony Scheduled for Mark “Marky” Meza, Jr.

The 21-year-old former Carpinteria resident was killed in the Borderline shooting.