• CREATE AN ACCOUNT
  • LOG.IN
  • CONTENTS
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • ARCHIVE
  • INFO | ADVERTISING | CONTACT US

  • Home
  • News
    • News Main Page
    • NewsFlash
  • A&E
    • A&E Main Page
    • Movie Times
    • TV Listings
    • A&E Blog
    • Art Galleries
    • Best Bets
  • Opinion
    • Opinion Main Page
    • Columns
    • Voices
    • Letters
    • In Memoriam
    • Obituaries
  • Events
    • Today
    • Search
    • Submit
    • Best Bets
  • Living
    • Living Main Page
    • Outdoors
    • Travel
    • Sports
    • Peeps
  • Food & Drink
    • Food & Drink Main Page
    • All Restaurants
    • Delivery
    • All Bars & Clubs
    • Drink Specials
    • Open Now
  • Outdoors
    • Outdoors Main Page
    • Outside Insider
    • Spotlight On
    • Features
  • Classifieds
    • Real Estate
    • Jobs
    • Autos
  • Personals
  • Obits

Circus


What Kind of Circus Is This?

Is Montecito’s Big Top Going to the Top Dogs?


Tuesday, September 11, 2007
By J'Amy Brown (Contact)
Article Tools
Print friendly
E-mail story
Contact an Editor
iPod friendly
Comments
Bookmark This
del.icio.us. del.icio.us.
Digg! Digg!
furl furl
google google
newsvine newsvine
reddit reddit
technorati technorati
Facebook Facebook
Yahoo! My Web 2.0 Yahoo!

Remember last week when I told you Montecito was just two clowns short of a three-ring circus? Well, I found the other two clowns, so come along as we stroll into the Montage big top for another week of thrills and spills!

Look in Ring-Two and you’ll find developer Rick Caruso precariously stranded atop his 51-foot, flag-tagged, story-poled Miramar trapeze. He’s perched there fresh from a jousting bout with some Miramar neighbors over private road relocation. Caruso created a minor gasp when he looked like he’d been thrown off balance by the abrupt end of neighborhood road talks. We hear Caruso wanted to talk road placement, while neighbors had a visions of heights, scale, and mass dancing in their heads.

Caruso was in no mood to change his agenda, so he left the meeting and withdrew his plan from a September 10 and September 19 Montecito Board of Architectural Review hearing, saying he will redesign the Miramar without the neighbor’s road. His action caused breathless on-lookers to ponder the Miramar fate: “Is he leaving? Is he abandoning the project? Is he falling out already?”

Story poles at the Miramar.
Click to enlarge photo

J'Amy Brown

Story poles at the Miramar.

No, as letter from his firm to the county’s Planning and Development staff implied: “This development (the road issue) is only a pause in the project that we remain fully committed to….It is our intent to resubmit our application within 60 days and acknowledge that you (Planning and Development staff) will have 30 additional days beyond the date of our submittal to review the revised application for complete.” So while Caruso didn’t tumble, his much-ballyhooed January construction date toppled to its much-expected demise.

With the high-wire theatrics in disarray, conspiracy theories spread. “This fortress is a far cry from what Caruso presented at the community meeting at El Mo,” said one. “It makes me wonder if this is a calculated bait and switch a la Westmont's ‘revised’ designs.”

Rick Caruso
Click to enlarge photo

Rick Caruso

A second theorist proposed Caruso could be a "straw dog" for Ty Warner. “Warner realized he was never going to get his project off the ground, so he sold the project to Caruso so [Warner] could buy it back after a Caruso completion!” He went on. “Caruso has no local ties, no hotel experience, the property closed escrow in an almost impossible 15 days and Caruso now claims not to have done the due diligence on the site, specifically about the salt water intrusion, percolation problems, and the road easements.” (Montage has a firm rule against printing rumors and baseless theories unless, of course, they fan the flames of intrigue and come certified for high entertainment value, as is with the cases above. This is a circus after all.)

Just to make this tight-rope walk have more audience appeal, on September 29 at a Heal the Ocean benefit, Caruso will be perched on the dais near none other than honorary chairs Julia-Louise Dreyfus and husband Brad Hall. They are, of course, part of the Miramar neighborhood collation of jousters who left Caruso stranded up top! How delicious will that disingenuous-smiles dinner be?

AND IN THIS RING: With the high-wire performers in a stalemate overhead, we’ll flip to a pink gel and move the spotlight to Coral Casino, debuting to dazzle and delight. But wait, some members look like sad-faced and are grumbling about a new Four Seasons Biltmore Hotel-imposed guest fee. It seems that members hosting Coral guests, even for a short social coffee klatch, are hit with a $25 entry fee. Add that to a cup of $4 coffee, and you’ll certainly have bitter java jolt to start off your day!

Photo Gallery

Coral Casino Re-Opens

On Friday, August 31, the Coral Casino partially re-opened after 18 months of remodeling. Here's an inside look.

Enlarge photos | View thumbnails

However, a solution is close at hand. We hear those guests can step right up and join Ty-Warner-World! We are swimming in rumors that Warner is within three weeks of offering a bevy of sun-and-fun-filled private club choices. And, just to make his get-up-and-go complete, we hear there is a long list (500 maybe) of wannabes dying to dive in.

Offerings, we hear, will start a minimum of $75K for the Coral and move right on to a $135,000 surf-‘n’-turf package for a Coral and Montecito Country Club combo. There’s also a $250K option, which allows a full four-club swing through Coral Casino, Sandpiper, Rancho San Marcos, and MCC.

THE BIGGEST SHOW ON EARTH: With our eyes dizzy with dollar signs, we spun into center ring last which of course was this weekend’s over-the-top Oprah-Obama $3 million political fund-raiser. Let me offer a peep, from the Montage point of view, of Flying Obama and his one-day Montecito whistle stop swing.

After greeting a supportive crowd at Santa Barbara City College, the star-politician headed straight for Nancy and Larry Koppleman’s Montecito seaside affair. Billed as a fundraiser, Obama acted like he had landed at a relaxation spa — a tranquility port, if you will, before the up-coming storm. Obama mixed and mingled with about 100 guests on the Koppleman’s umbrella-laced beachfront patio. There he seemed refreshed by an ocean view, salt air breezes, and an al fresco lunch, including an Eli’s Chicago Cheesecake, flown in by the Koppleman’s to give the Illinois Senator a familiar touchstone of home.

Photo Gallery

Oprah's Obama Bash

Check out these shots by J'Amy Brown of the hoopla surrounding the Barack Obama fundraiser held by Oprah Winfrey on Saturday, September 8.

Hanging at the block party with Barack.

Enlarge photos | View thumbnails

One guest told Montage they felt so close to the Senator by the end of the event they were calling him by his first name. “Barack was relaxed and happy, talked with everyone and shook hands,” the guest said. “We all were in love, and we felt like we knew him when he left.” Another Koppleman guest, who attended Oprah’s later, said Op’s event offered a musical treat of Stevie Wonder and Gospel music, but it was the more intimate Koppleman-Obama experience that lingered in his mind.

And who were our who’s who at the 1,500-plus packed Oprah event? First of all, the real community stars in my book were few nearby neighbors, who, un-invited to real O-O event, hosted a block party, complete with cardboard cut outs of Oprah and Obama. A Sheriff’s deputy and the postman, both having fought Op’s happening, lined up for a loving potluck and a real Montecito welcome!

Among the 100 Montecito marquee named at the non-plastic Oprah event were pals like the Towbes, Barbakows, Nickols, and Velozes, who sold Oprah her East Valley home. Obama was seen mixing with Julia Dreyfus and Brad Hall, David and Jan Crosby, Linda Evans, Lois Capps, Marjorie Layden, Gay Browne, Nina Terzian, with her daughter Kristy, Sue Firestone, Mike and Carolyn Balaban, and Kat and Terrance Ladd. And that’s just a few of the folks who lolled on Oprah’s lush lawn on take-home souvenir blankets.

VIEW FROM OUTSIDE THE BIG TOP: Even though I’d already paid my entry fee, I was nixed from the Oprah-do after my article two weeks ago, which is too bad because I could have brought along my very own wet blanket. But I was able to wonder, as this affair unfolded with 25 rolling buses spewing fumes in my face, how many times our tiny 3000-parcel enclave can handle this 2000-plus-guest beating?

J'Amy Brown hangs out with the big Os.
Click to enlarge photo

J'Amy Brown hangs out with the big Os.

Does star-power now mandate thoughtlessness, where a tacky tacked up sign alerts neighbors of weekend road closures and traffic on-slaught instead of a personal call or hand written note? Unnoticed, as required by permit, Oprah’s neighbors were left to scramble to cancel long scheduled yard work, parties and pre-advertised open houses as well and even the mail truck had to fight his way on the road.

Are we now so polarized by issues and so busy climbing some invisible social ladder that we have lost all community graciousness and unified concern? Will the kind of onslaught of a huge mass brought here by Oprah lead to an over-encumbered, ill-equipped police force who, while trying to manage stars, media, and 2000 guests, become over-zealous with locals, no longer knowing us by sight and scaring us with their demeanor and officious reaction?

Initially, this clown was excited and oh-so-proud to welcome the likes of Oprah and Ty and Rick to our neighborhood tent. I thought each one of them understood and loved what we had here — a beautiful, quiet, friendly, thoughtful community.

But today this clown wears a sad face and sheds a tear. This weekend punctuated the fact that the community of Montecito that I knew and loved and fought so hard to preserve is fractured and gone.

There’s a new circus in town and the neon is blinding. Unfortunately, the glare may be too bright for this old barker to go on.

Please contact J.amy.brown@att.net with your thoughts about the future of Montage.

Story Help (Click-ability)
Double-clicking on any word or phrase in this story will open a reference window with definitions and links to other reference material.

Comments

Discussion Guidelines

Caruso Affiliated's Matt Middlebrook has taken exception to my reporting Miramar rumors in this column without allowing an opportunity for the Caruso group to respond. While I clearly labeled the items as purely amusing rumor, I am delighted Matt has come forward to respond so we can set the record straight. To that end, Ladies and Gentlemen, let me introduce Matt Middlebrook:

J'Amy -- Love your way with words, if only they were true. Three points:

1. In discussion with our neighbors about the road, the issue of heights, etc. was never a focus of the talks. Our discussions were only about the creek, and the end of the discussions came after nearly 5 months of talks.

2. The Ty Warner straw man theory, while titillating, is a bunch of nonsense, as is the absurd quote from the unnamed source stating, "[Caruso] claims not to have done the due diligence on the site, specifically about the salt water intrusion, percolation problems, and the road easements." We've done extensive due diligence which is why we're so confident we can build a great hotel on this site.

3. The plan we presented to MBAR was nearly identical to the concepts we presented to the community at the public meeting at the Presbyterian Church and at dozens of meetings, both big and small since. Our approach from day one has been direct community engagement, and those discussions over the months have helped us make a better plan for the hotel. And we'll continue to work with the community as we redesign the project (which we've already started!)

Facts aren't nearly as fun as the rumors, but figured I might as well get these points on the record. Look forward to seeing you around town (since you apparently lost my phone number).

Your loyal and devoted reader,
Matt Middlebrook, Vice President, Caruso Affiliated

JAMY (J'Amy Brown)
September 12, 2007 at 1:38 p.m. (Suggest removal)

I think a bait and switch would have been if Westmont proposed lower buildings closer to the center of campus and then changed and went with the taller buildings closer to the perimeter.

The college called for a pause to the hearing process after it received thoughtful feedback from the decision-makers. We then returned with a plan that reduced the heights of buildings and moved them closer to the center of campus resulting in a much more desirable plan for the college and our neighbors.

WestmontScott (anonymous profile)
September 12, 2007 at 5:05 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Finally someone brave enough to take on Oprah.

Everyone is so concerned with trying to be part of her "in list" that they are turning a blind eye to what she has done to this community. From the day she purchased the old Bacon estate Montecito was irrefutably changed. Carloads of star-seekers, a sight not seen before in Montecito, arrived due to the national publicity of her purchase price.

Everyone waited with baited breath to see what Oprah would do to become part of the community. She made an appearance at a sold out Girls Inc luncheon, and hasn't given back anything to the community since then. She has taken, however, and taken a lot.

Subsequent to that Girl's Inc. luncheon and connections she made locally, she pulled tremendous donor dollars out of the Santa Barbara community for her school project in Africa. Not that it isn't a very worthy cause, but she has sucked up so much of the available donor money for Santa Barbara that a number of local charities are actual suffering.

Then there was her Legonds Ball. I don't dispute her ability to throw a party if she wants, but her unique celebrity along with that of her WELL PUBLICIZED guest list brought the paparazzi out in force. The helicopters which hover 500 feet off the ground ALL day circling her property (including many others near by) are so loud that they can be heard inside a home with all the windows and doors shut. Not a really comfortable thought in the middle of the summer with no air conditioning!

Now this party. Close to 2000 people, publicized nationally in advance, in a rural residential area with narrow tiny roads. The poor neighbors weren't even notified that they would be prohibited from driving on their very own street until a sign was posted lterally the night before. The music was so loud (Stevie Wonder is great but not when you are trying to put your baby down for a nap) that it was heard from one end of Montecito to the other. The sound checks went on from early morning all day disrupting people's lives.

So...good for Oprah, she threw a great party, made lots of money for Mr. Obama, and had a wonderful time. Too bad she cares so little for her neighbors and the community of Montecito. To those whom much is given, much is expected. Oprah, we expected more from you! Like curtisy and consideration.

montecitomatron (anonymous profile)
September 14, 2007 at 8:11 p.m. (Suggest removal)

Post a comment

Username:
Password: (Forgotten your password?)

Comment:

EVENT CALENDAR

Previous Month | Next Month

Today's Events Best Bets Submit an Event

Local Weather

Currently:
Clear Sky
Temperature:
57.9°
Wind:
3 E

Surf Report
  • Specials
  • InPrint
  • Top Emails
  • Blue Green Guide 2008
  • Summer Camp Guide 2008
  • Wedding Guide 2008
  • SBIFF 2008 All Access
  • 2008 Election Coverage
  • Best of Reader's Poll 2007
  • Calendar of Fundraisers
  • Local Bands
  • Kid's Mother's Day Issue
  • Made in Santa Barbara
  • Tea Fire 2008
  • Local Heroes 2008
  • Chamomile Café
  • Reprieve for Modoc Road Evictees
  • Which Canyon Will Burn Next?
  • Portland’s Rock Revivalists Head to Muddy Waters
  • Thanksgiving Turkey
  1. Saving the Riviera
  2. School District’s Special Ed Director Quits
  3. Obituary for Susan Lake
  4. Hannah-Beth Jackson Concedes to Tony Strickland
  5. UCSB’s Fall Dance Concert 2008
  6. From Black Friday to Blessed Friday
  • CREATE AN ACCOUNT
  • LOG.IN
  • CONTENTS
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • ARCHIVE
  • INFO | ADVERTISING | CONTACT US
Google
 
Independent.com Web
Copyright ©2008 Santa Barbara Independent, Inc. Reproduction of material from any Independent.com pages without written permission is strictly prohibited. If you believe an Independent.com user or any material appearing on Independent.com is copyrighted material used without proper permission, please click here.
This is our Privacy Policy.