The Creek Runneth Again

County Supes Scrap Mitigation and Rule in Favor of Steelheads

by Ethan Stewart

Despite being yanked from last week’s Board of Supervisors meeting agenda amidst a flurry of emails from the involved parties, an appeal by the Land Trust for Santa Barbara was unanimously approved by county supervisors this week. The approval clears the way for long-percolating restoration plans for Arroyo Hondo Creek to move forward, free of the burden of the labor- and cost-intensive mitigations the Board initially required. In August, the Board approved the Land Trust-led Arroyo Hondo Steelhead Passage project, essentially giving the go-ahead for the removal of a large concrete culvert near the base of the train trestle where the creek meets the ocean, the addition of grouted rock, and the resulting creation of a new lagoon area. Much to the dismay of the Land Trust, the Board had also added the stipulation that the construction be mitigated by a 3-to-1 ratio of assorted native plants upstream from the restoration area. After this week’s vote, the Land Trust needs only to replant vegetation and habitat at a 1-to-1 ratio in the immediate restoration area.

The Arroyo Hondo Ranch was acquired as a preserve in 2001 by the Land Trust, and its 782 acres make up more than a quarter of the Arroyo Hondo Creek watershed area, with the remainder falling under the jurisdiction of the Forest Service. According to Land Trust director Michael Feeney, the reconstruction of the lower 550 feet of the creek would result in the opening up of approximately six miles of vital steelhead breeding habitat. And while associated agencies like NOAA, California Fish and Game, and CalTrans all felt the proposed restoration and its 1-to-1 mitigation was more than reasonable, county staff countered that all projects — whether they be environmentally motivated or development-based — should be forced to comply with a 3-to-1 mitigation ratio. The nonprofit, volunteer-based Land Trust feared the 3-to-1 ratio would not only be overkill but could also possibly slow the project’s completion, if not derail it. “All the plants we are taking out, all the areas we are restoring, we are going to restore to a much better condition than they are today,” explained Feeney to the supes this week. He went on to point out that the 3-to-1 ratio didn’t exist anywhere in county code.

Adding further complexity to the Arroyo Hondo Creek issue — and no doubt fueling the widespread email speculation that the plan could forever remain saddled with the 3-to-1 ratio — were the ill feelings currently hanging over the board. Supervisor Brooks Firestone in particular was peeved after an enviro-led appeal essentially killed a Gaviota Bridge project despite the fact that the county had sunk $900,000 into its planning and had secured approximately $6 million in federal funds. Observers thought Firestone’s frustration over the outcome of the bridge project would influence his vote on Arroyo Hondo. However, in the end, Supervisor Firestone surprised everyone by making the motion to approve the appeal — though not before lamenting the Gaviota Bridge meltdown — and even took things one step further by asking staff to come back to the board at a later date with a plan for dealing with future mitigation ratio debates.

To submit a comment on this article, email or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email

Be succinct, constructive, and relevant to the story. Leaving a comment means you agree to our Discussion Guidelines. We like civilized discourse. We don't like spam, lying, profanity, harassment or personal attacks.

comments powered by Disqus
event calendar sponsored by:
This Week's Issue

Montecito Pushes Back on Streamlined Rebuild Process

Not so fast with fast-track rebuilding, leaders tell the county

St. George Files Suit Against Gelb for Unpaid Debt

Pair of Isla Vista landlords in legal tussle over property sales costs.

Thousands of Plaintiffs Added to Refugio Oil Spill Case

Litigation follows footsteps of 1969 Union Oil spill attorneys.

Push Comes to Shove Between Law Enforcement and Mental Health

County supervisors confront too many needs with not enough money.

Helicopter Hits Electrical Wires, Starts Small Fire

A crop duster hit power lines in Ellwood Canyon.