WEATHER »

Ecologists Solve Biodiversity Puzzle

Niche Differences Are Answer to Controversy, Scientists Say


UCSB’s Jonathan Levine claims to have put the last doubts to rest in a long-standing ecological debate with the result of a study, by himself and colleague Dr. Janneke Hille Ris Lambers, proving that niche differences are the key to biodiversity. “Our study provided some of the first field-based evidence that niche differences were truly driving species diversity, resolving a big controversy in ecology,” said Levine, an associate professor in the Department of Ecology, Evolution, and Marine Biology at UCSB.

The study, published August 12 in the journal Nature, was inspired by a “century-old biodiversity puzzle,” according to Levine. Ecologists had not found definitive evidence explaining how different species are able co-exist without all the lesser equipped competition being overtaken by the strongest competitor. Ecologists had pondered what allowed different species to survive in the same environment, when they are tapping into the same pool of resources, but their theories lacked the support of evidence from the field. Ecologists were focused on two main theories: Either species are able to co-exist because niche differences allow them to share an environment and its resources, or they are so equally suited to their environment that no one species is able to topple the competition. When the latter theory was posed about 10 years ago, said Levine, “there was little evidence from the field to support the classic niche ideas. Our study changed this.” The niche theory was assumed to be correct based on mathematical models, Levine said, but until this study it had never actually been tested, either in the lab or out in the field.

The study, conducted in the San Rafael mountains, simulated the elimination of niche differences within experimental communities of annual plants, and watched as species diversity declined quickly in the face of the change. According to Levine, this is the most telling evidence ever provided for the theory that niche differences are key in biodiversity. Examples of these niche differences can be found in many places in nature, including Santa Barbara’s own backyard. “[One] can turn to local oak savannas, where large oak trees with deep roots co-occur with short annual grasses. But how all the different types of annual grasses co-occur is bit of mystery, and could result from each of the species being roughly equal competitors,” Levine said. “Alternatively, less obvious niche differences might control their abundance too, like differences in rooting depth or the seasonality of their growth.” Although the study was conducted mainly for the advancement of pure science, Levine added, it is also true that understanding biodiversity will play a pivotal role in its conservation. The loss of biodiversity in plant systems is extremely detrimental to humans, he said, and this study sheds light on how biodiversity can be preserved.

To submit a comment on this article, email letters@independent.com or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email tips@independent.com.



Be succinct, constructive, and relevant to the story. Leaving a comment means you agree to our Discussion Guidelines. We like civilized discourse. We don't like spam, lying, profanity, harassment or personal attacks.

comments powered by Disqus
event calendar sponsored by:

Muslim Students Organize Vigil for New Zealand Victims

Attack that killed 51 people described as “act of pure evil and terrorism” by UCSB students.

News Commentary: Death Penalty Shouts and Whispers

Governor's reprieve has little effect in Santa Barbara, except in the Han case.

Goleta Planning Commissioners Just Say ‘No’

Vociferous comments from Old Town residents help tip the balance for oversight on cannabis storefront applications.

Bullet Holes Found in Goleta Barbershop Window

Public's help requested in shooting investigation.

Free Emergency Response Training

The Independent is hosting a CERT class with County Fire's Mike Eliason.