Latinos are both disappointed and frustrated by the failure of the DREAM Act in Congress. The main problem was not that Republicans wanted to derail it– everyone knew that - but that Democrats didn’t have their act together, and some joined the Republicans and voted against it. With those five Democrat votes against, the DREAM Act fell five votes short of passing. If those five Democrat votes would’ve been pro-DREAM, the bill would have reached the Senate floor, and could have passed by a simple majority.
Unfortunately, this shows the reality of the Democratic Party. It is disjointed, and unable to organize in order to vote as one. This leaves Latinos out in the cold, and with no clear option as to which political party to turn to. Maybe now is the time for an independent candidate to come forward for 2012, uniting the Latino vote and taking it away from both parties.
It feels even worse that the DREAM Act failure comes on the heels of the passing of the “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy reversal, which allows for gays in the military to be as openly gay as they may. The country is focusing in celebrating this great success, of course; however, very little has been said in the media about the irrational vote on the DREAM Act.
Why irrational? Because who can possibly think that for youth - who didn’t come to this country willfully, but were brought at a young age by their parents - to become well-educated adults, paying their taxes, and their Social Security, and spending on consumer products, is not something that our country will benefit from? We’re talking about 1.2 million immigrant youth in this group, according experts. Republicans, frankly, are blindly obsessed with fighting anything that could look like amnesty. Whether it’s beneficial or not, they don’t care.
As upsetting as the failure of the DREAM Act is, it is not surprising to those who have been paying attention to the writing on the wall. When the Democrats had the majority in both houses, the Democratic leadership wasn’t able to cash in on that political power. Now things have changed, the fight for the presidential race in 2012 is on, and Republicans will for sure obstruct anything that Obama wants to do.
Although Republicans say that they are interested in passing a comprehensive immigration reform bill, it is not expected that they will act on it until “our borders are secured,” as they have expressed. But, curiously enough, they keep opposing the bills that fund border security. It seems that the “status quo” is working fine for them. In the meantime, we can expect more abuse of power, and inhumane treatment for those who are undocumented.


Print friendly
E-mail story
Tip Us Off
Comments
Share Article
Myspace




Previous Month



Comments
Excellent piece in Noozhawk "Why the DREAM act failed." DREAM was simply a massive amnesty for 1/6 to 1/3 of illegal aliens currently in the U.S.
http://www.noozhawk.com/opinions/arti...
revisionist (anonymous profile)
December 27, 2010 at 6:57 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Sure, the young people who'd gain citizenship with the DREAM act would have been terrific American citizens. No doubt about that at all.
I'm uncomfortable with the millions of terrific potential citizens in other countries who have applied the lawful way for US citizenship and been denied. The DREAM act was terribly unfair to those applicants who followed the law.
We thought we'd solved this whole problem in 1986.... with the last amnesty. What happened?
snugspout (anonymous profile)
December 27, 2010 at 9:41 a.m. (Suggest removal)
If the Dream Act is only about allowing people who were brought here as kids to pursue education, I'm for it. At this time, I don't have all the details of the bill.
As for the Democratic party, they, like the Republican party, do not represent the public. Obama, like probable future president Sarah Palin, is a creation of the media and did nothing special to merit his current status. The average American will vote for someone based on a thirty-second sound byte and slick campaign ads but will rarely evaluate candidates/issues individually. Politicians are also very good at playing one side against the other. Many talk about "coming in the right way" so that they appear to be anti-illegal immigration while at the same time trying to pass themselves off as pro "Latino".
Keep in mind to that a well-educated populace is a threat to the power structure. People on one end will oppose the Dream Act which ensures kids will not get educated, while people on the other end keep pushing for Spanish-language services which guarentees that people will not learn English.
Welcome to the dirty world of politics.
billclausen (anonymous profile)
December 30, 2010 at 7:27 p.m. (Suggest removal)