Judging the Judge

by Martha Sadler

A panel of judges investigating misconduct charges against Santa Barbara Superior Court Judge Diana Hall (pictured) issued its findings this week. The special masters found that Hall violated judicial ethics on three separate occasions in 2001: by driving drunk, by disguising the source of a campaign donation, and by improperly asking a prosecutor the reason why he issued a peremptory challenge to remove her from hearing one of his cases. The latter count was the most egregious, according to the panel, comprising “willful misconduct” because Hall knew she was not allowed to ask that question, but did so anyway; she then denied it. Moreover, she committed this violation in her capacity as a judge. However, the panel also listed several mitigating factors, including that she posed the question in a calm manner and out of genuine surprise, since it was unusual for a prosecutor to recuse her. The panel found that Hall’s anxiety about people discovering that she was cohabiting with a same-sex lover was a major contributing factor to the other two counts. Hall drove drunk in flight from an argument in which her partner threatened to disclose the nature of their relationship, and she lied under oath about the source of the campaign contribution because it was a gift from her partner. The panel also praised Hall’s “long and otherwise exemplary career.” The California Commission on Judicial Performance will determine how the findings will affect Hall — whose term ends in 2008 — later this year.

To submit a comment on this article, email or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email

Be succinct, constructive, and relevant to the story. Leaving a comment means you agree to our Discussion Guidelines. We like civilized discourse. We don't like spam, lying, profanity, harassment or personal attacks.

comments powered by Disqus
event calendar sponsored by:

Steven Seagal Named Special Envoy by Russia

The former Santa Ynez resident is a Russian citizen.

County Services Transitioning Away from Montecito Disaster Center

Post-1/9 support will still be available at

Goleta Limits Accessory Dwelling Units to 800 Square Feet

The city followed most of the state's ADU rules, though two large projects swept through before the ...

New Coast Guard Cutter Named After Fallen Officer

Terrell Horne III was murdered near Santa Cruz Island in 2012.

SBCC Promise a Draw for High School Grads

Program offers two free years to dedicated students.