Quarantining Isla Vista

Good for you, Nick. [Angry Poodle, ”Dewormed but Not Desquirmed,” 4/15/10.]

I too saw the constitutional issues in the beach closure, but no one with whom I attempted to discuss this seemed to see anything untoward, or even to recognize the larger issues here—as, incidentally, few recognize the same issues in the Isla Vista “quarantine” at Halloween.

An analogous situation would arise if the City of Santa Barbara, for precisely the same reasons given by the Board of Supervisors to justify the Isla Vista beach closure (public drunkeness, fighting, litter, filth, petty crime, costs of policing) attempted to shut down Fiesta, or for that matter lower State Street on any and every weekend. Same reasoning (or no reasoning at all) would apply, but of course that would never happen. The restaurants, clubs, bars and hotels would scream about loss of sales tax, bed tax, etc. These factors, much more than any Constitutional issue, would prevent any such radical action at the expense of “legitimate” commerce.—Des O’Neill

To submit a comment on this article, email or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email

event calendar sponsored by:

North Hall Takeover: 50 Years Later

Actor Danny Glover keynotes UCSB conference.

Elliot Laps the Field in SBCC Fundraising

She’s raised more than every other candidate combined.

Foro Público Proporciona Estado de Inmigración

Este evento gratuito será traducido en español.

Public Forum to Provide Immigration Status Update

The Santa Barbara event is free, open to the public, and will provide Spanish translation.

Family Favorite Palazzio Italian Restaurant Won’t Reopen

Water damage and downtime killed the State Street eatery.