Paul Wellman
Santa Barbara Body Therapy Institute foot reflexology class, as taught by Katie Mickey.
Getting Well in Newer Ways
A Report from the Frontlines of Santa Barbara’s Alternative Health Movement
Thursday, October 7, 2010
While there’s plenty that’s peachy about modern medicine, pills aren’t always the perfect pathway to health. Even stubborn and suspicious Western doctors seem to be admitting as much these days, and there’s no better place to experiment with alternative means of wellness than Santa Barbara, where every treatment imaginable—from the truly helpful to the downright zany—is lurking around the corner. Never one to shy away from my inner guinea pig, I recently subjected myself to various pricks, pokes, and plunges to deliver the following report.
Paul Wellman
Coyolicatzi Cortes gets a Glutathione wB12 infusion.
IV Treatments at the Integrative Medicine Center of Santa Barbara
The only thing distinguishing this facility from the everyday doctor’s office is the distinct smell and sight of vitamins—well, that and the fact that you could’ve recently found me in the back room hooked up to an intravenous drip of vitamins, minerals, and amino acids. The offspring of the late, popular Dr. Bob Young, the center is a primary care facility but one that employs technologies new and old to get to the bottom of your problems.
“We’re focusing on primary care medicine, but we’re doing it in a holistic way,” said Dr. Kristi Wrightson, a naturopathic physician and dietician who now operates the center with Dr. Scott Saunders, who focuses on chronic diseases, and herbalist and Reiki master Jennifer Vasilakos, who blends traditional Chinese and Ayurvedic medicine with Western herbal treatments. “We’re not just thinking about what medication will get rid of the problem. We’re thinking about what’s causing the problems and what’s going to be the best way you can optimally return to health.” That includes everything from assessing one’s nutrition and determining emotional underliers to more obscure approaches, such as photoluminescence (in which UV rays treat the blood) and hyperbaric oxygen (for restoring oxygen to the brain of stroke victims).
When I was there, I was on the verge of getting a head cold, so my treatment meant mainlining a dose of “Myers’ cocktail”—which blends magnesium, calcium, four Vitamin Bs, and Vitamin C into a treatment for everything from allergies and asthma to fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue—and a boost of glutathione, which supposedly can stop the spread of cancer, fight the effects of Parkinson’s, and otherwise make your body a happier place. Aside from the discomfort of having a needle in my arm for an hour, I felt like a champ leaving the center, and my cold was put at bay. No wonder some folks come for immune-boosting treatments regularly.
The clinic, which takes insurance and does not require a referral, is located at 601 East Arrellaga Street, Suite 101. Call 963-1824 or see drsaundersmd.com.
By Paul Wellman
Reflexology at the S.B. Body Therapy Institute
It’s just past happy hour on a Friday evening, and about 10 people are pressing their bare feet into golf balls inside this longtime institute on Quarantina Street. We’re all there for a free class about reflexology, the practice of using foot and hand massage to soothe other parts of the body. It’s a technique that’s never been fully embraced by Western medicine, but one that institute director Katie Mickey has been using for 25 years with great results. Just that morning, Mickey had used reflexology to treat a man with degenerative spinal disc problems, taking his pain from excruciating down to almost nothing, simply by pressing on his feet because massaging his afflicted back wasn’t possible.
“Being able to address pain relief is a big issue,” said Mickey. But she believes it can do more than that because so many modern health issues are related to a “deficiency of electrons” in which an “abundance of free radicals” cause inflammation, cancer, heart disease, and 80 other pathologies. “The reason we’re so deficient in electrons is that, as a culture, we are lacking grounding—we’ve insulated ourselves from the earth,” she explained, referring to footwear, raised floors, and the like. “We can dramatically change our inflammatory profile when we get grounded.” Reflexology breaks up the metabolic waste in our feet to allow that grounding, said Mickey, and works both to relieve stress and detoxify.
A few days later, Mickey went to work on my tired feet for nearly an hour. All signs were healthy until she stumbled upon the zone that corresponds to my gallbladder, which was sensitive, she said, because my job involves making lots of decisions. Once those kinks were smoothed out, I was set free. Are my organs and glands any healthier? Not sure. Best foot massage of my life? Without a doubt.
The institute, which offers free introductory classes, professional training, and both affordable student-run and market-rate professional sessions in all types of massage, is located at 516 North Quarantina Street. Call 966-5802 or see sbbti.com.
By Paul Wellman
Diane Feingold gives water release therapy to her son Julian.
Submerged in a warm pool, my body is carefully flopped about, like a beach towel being shaken of sand in slow motion. My underwater mind, at first worried about when my next breath would come, forgets momentarily about the needs of my lungs. It is instead lost in a full state of utter relaxation as it floats about weightlessly, my limbs occasionally stretched, my muscles frequently massaged. Welcome to the pleasures of water release therapy (WRT), a modality invented by my former yoga teacher Diane Feingold, who took the tenets of Watsu (or “water shiatsu”) and developed a much deeper practice.
“I’m focusing on being fully present in mind, body, and emotion, connecting deeply with all levels of being,” explained Feingold, whose clients include both those seeking simple relaxation and others with more critical needs, such as rape victims, fibromyalgia sufferers, and folks with serious neck and back problems. “It allows me to support someone in a space where they can move in ways they cannot move on land. It helps people really integrate a lot of healing, a lot of letting go. People can free themselves up of things that might be in the way of living fully in their life.”
Working mostly in a specially designed backyard pool in the Hidden Valley neighborhood, Feingold offers sessions lasting from one hour to three days, and also trains others who want to incorporate WRT into their practices. Citing patients who cry the entire session because of being held close and others who make psychological breakthroughs due to the submersions, Feingold—whose body frequently “jolts” during sessions in order to help clients’ unwanted energy release into the water—believes her work is “extremely transformational.”
When my session ended, the world certainly seemed brighter, and I remarked that the experience was like slipping into another world. Laughed Feingold, “That’s the world I live in.” I was jealous.
Comments
The claims in this piece are amusingly idiotic, but one in particular might be dangerous: Perhaps someone connected to the reality-based medical community can clarify this, but I thought that research has shown than excess glutathione, rather than supposedly being able to "stop the spread of cancer," actually protects cancer cells from the effects of treatments used to attack them.
pk (anonymous profile)
October 7, 2010 at 8:11 a.m. (Suggest removal)
I doubt they're interested in the accuracy of the recommendations of anyone interviewed for this article. Quite frankly, I find it less than amusing, to say the least. What would be humorous, however, would be watching them squirm after asking them to provide credible, peer reviewed research that substantiates any of the claims they've made.
Where alt-med scams actually do provide assistance and supplement the legitimate medical community is with mental health, although the practitioners aren't trained to do so. They can take more time with patients and talk to them at length about their problems and are more focused on subjective elements like "well-being." So what they really offer is a form of unlicensed psychotherapy.
People, people, people! None of these garbage treatments do anything but empty your wallet. Readers looking for effective medical care would be wise to follow the recommedations of trained professionals, i.e. nobody interviewed in this article.
TheJesus (anonymous profile)
October 7, 2010 at 4:33 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Well said, son.
Don't forget the power of the placebo.
God (anonymous profile)
October 7, 2010 at 4:39 p.m. (Suggest removal)
FYI to do some research on the scientific reason reflexology helps the body....."breaks up metabolic waste??" . Come on Mickey, there is no science to this and we need more reflexologists to begin to use correct neuro-physiological explanations as any touch therapy modality should be able to. Research by Dr. J. Manzanares shows what those 'deposits' are in the feet via biopsies--they are NOT wastes, but rather an abundance of nerve fibers, shown clearly in the tissue when biopsied. NO science for metabolic wastes, crystals, toxins, etc. - read more under RESEARCH on the Reflexology Association of America site at www.reflexology-usa.org. Here's to the profession of reflexology and educators passing on anatomically correct information and educate the public with the science and not the confusing lingo that has no rigor.
janny (anonymous profile)
October 7, 2010 at 4:43 p.m. (Suggest removal)
and by the way to Paul, the writer......if I had been the one you were interviewing, I would have made sure (as a professional reflexologist) that you reported the news in a fashion that your readers could relate to - maybe even do some of your own research as a responsible journalist....and find out what reflexology in the true therapeutic sense is about. It is not a foot rub, thank you from all of the trained, professionals in the field - and if that is what you got, check out the next 'spa' and you'll find the same service.
Is this responsible reporting? or was it your intention to send a tongue in cheek message, instead of saying what you meant - or were you really this poor at writing - to insult the intelligence of your readers AND the thousands of yay, integrative medicine practitioners, nurses, even Dr. Oz who point to the $3million dollar grant given by the Natlional Ist. of Health to study reflexology and breast cancer!
I'm insulted at reading this, and thought what a moron....both of them.....to write such an article!
Why did you waste yours and her time?
Why not write something that is useful and supports wellness in folks needing to be educated.
.. listen to this readers......Mickey did you not get that he was insulting YOU!?? I"m done!
"All signs were healthy until she stumbled upon the zone that corresponds to my gallbladder, which was sensitive, she said, because my job involves making lots of decisions. Once those kinks were smoothed out, I was set free. Are my organs and glands any healthier? Not sure. Best foot massage of my life? Without a doubt.
janny (anonymous profile)
October 7, 2010 at 5:08 p.m. (Suggest removal)
Yeah, janny, I'm insulted too ... by all the woo.
"A 2009 systematic review of randomised controlled trials concluded that the latest available evidence does not show that reflexology is an effective treatment for any medical condition." (That's from Wiki)
"Reflexology has almost no potential for direct harm, but its ability to mislead well-meaning people into believing that it can be used for screening for health problems, or that it has real therapeutic value could lead to serious problems:" (That's from ref #12 at Wiki)
Reflexology is a technique to remove green pieces of special paper from your wallet or purse, nothing more. I hope you enjoyed your trip on the woo train, Matt, but wonder if you sleep well knowing that you are potentially harming people.
SezMe (anonymous profile)
October 8, 2010 at 1:53 a.m. (Suggest removal)
Well I for one certainly don't need to be lectured by these commenters who are worshippers of western medicine. We have such a terribly unhealthy society because as the article articulated "peer-reviewed" western medicine attacks the problem and not the cause of the health issues we face.
With no experience and very little knowledge of the treatments outlined in the article, it is actually sad that I have a lot more faith in the treatments above than I have in western medicine, which while it has made strides in it's own twisted way has proven a miserable failure for humanity.
Unfortunately, the government through it's corporate medicine structure has forced everybody into the western medicine establishment, so alternative treatments are only for the rich who have extra money since government and corporate insurers don't pay for alternative treatments. That makes them expensive. If people could choose their own insurance, they could get insurance that covered some of the more expensive alternative treatments while having inexpensive premiums to to allow them to use their own money to pay for whatever lesser expensive treatments they desired. This would lower the cost of the type of treatments outlined above to the point where it wouldn't matter that much if they didn't work.
The fact is that everybody pools their money into our crock western medicine system and so that is what we get... the industry is govt. controlled and used for profit of lobbying firms, and the treatments outlined above cannot be patented so the industry can't profit and won't support them. That is really what it comes down to. So while you are blathering on about "peer reviewed science" just remember to take into consideration the profit motive and how our entire system of govt. controlled healthcare is under the thumb of the industry. There is plenty of stuff in this world that is true that has not been peer reviewed.
In the mean time everybody is crying for the government to cover their healthcare, when all that is going to do is direct more money towards the medical industrial complex and away from inexpensive alternative treatments which often times work much better.
loonpt (anonymous profile)
October 8, 2010 at 2:41 p.m. (Suggest removal)
"With no experience and very little knowledge of the treatments outlined in the article, it is actually sad that I have a lot more faith in the treatments above than I have in western medicine ..."--loonpt
How odd that you would admit at the beginning that there is absolutely no basis for listening to anything further you might have to say.
That said, I won't argue that there is much to be fixed about the health care system in the USA. No doubt. But that does not suggest that incorporating woo into the mix will make it better. The battle is NOT western vs. eastern medicine. It is all about using evidence-based medicine.
SezMe (anonymous profile)
October 8, 2010 at 3:01 p.m. (Suggest removal)
loonpt
It hardly takes a "worshipper of western medicine" to point out the idiocy of statements like "glutathione...supposedly can stop the spread of cancer"; "so many modern health issues are related to a 'deficiency of electrons'” because "as a culture...we’ve insulated ourselves from the earth” due to "footwear, raised floors, and the like"; "Reflexology breaks up the metabolic waste in our feet"; there's a zone of the foot relating to the condition of the gallbladder, the sensitivity of which relates to the stress of "making lots of decisions"; and comments from someone who invented a therapy "whose body frequently 'jolts' during sessions in order to help clients’ unwanted energy release into the water."
If your ideological distaste for the medical business leads you to have more faith in these sorts of nonsense than in reality-based medicine, I hope that you never need to seek treatment for any serious condition.
pk (anonymous profile)
October 9, 2010 at 7:51 a.m. (Suggest removal)
ps
My final paragraph should have referred to "the traditional medical business." People like those cited in article are also part of the "medical business"--a rather lucrative part that happens to be based more on ignorance, crackpot theories, and credulity than on scientific evidence.
pk (anonymous profile)
October 9, 2010 at 8:03 a.m. (Suggest removal)
On the subject of massage (and barefoot sports massage in particular) I really like a quote from John Harris, who also frequently teaches at SB Body Therapy Institute. "I don't diagnose. I don't cure. I just step on it and if someone feels better when I'm done, great!" I like the humility and general lack of "woo" there.
One thing medical science has confirmed is that stress has a serious and significantly negative effect on health. If massage is a good way to address stress, then clearly it has associated positive effects on health. I believe that reflexology does this, and the addition of a nice big placebo supported by confirmation bias ("I paid a lot for this treatment, so it must be effective") probably doesn't hurt either.
agh (anonymous profile)
October 21, 2010 at 9:39 a.m. (Suggest removal)