<b>JERSEY SNORE:</b>  Kristen Wiig plays a washed-up playwright who returns home to New Jersey in the disheveled dramedy <em>Girl Most Likely</em>.

JERSEY SNORE: Kristen Wiig plays a washed-up playwright who returns home to New Jersey in the disheveled dramedy Girl Most Likely.

Review: Girl Most Likely

Kristen Wiig, Annette Bening, and Christopher Fitzgerald star in a film written by Michelle Morgan and directed by Shari Springer Berman and Robert Pulcini.

In American show biz as we know it, a strange phenomenon and collective culture-shock sensation take root when our beloved Saturday Night Live cast members try to make that leap from small to big screen. As a ripe f’rinstance, although the skit-comedy queen Kristen Wiig has already proved her big-screen readiness in Bridesmaids, it’s a bigger stretch to fully accept her as the lead in Girl Most Likely. We’re accustomed to her stellar work in small-plate, piecemeal, skit-based form, as, say, the Target Lady, the crazed, tiny-handed loon in the Lawrence Welk bits, or one of my more absurd favorites, as Virgania Horsen, the Pony Express mailwoman.

Wiig is up front and in the extended spotlight in Girl Most Likely, a film that wavers between winning our affections and losing itself in a swirl of contrary emotions, modes, and genre choices. She is your not-so-basic girl adrift, a thirtysomething writer’s-blocked playwright in N.Y.C. whose failing romance has driven her to fake a suicide and ultimately to go home again, to Ocean City, New Jersey. There, the family unit includes a “special” brother (Christopher Fitzgerald) with a crab obsession so intense that he invents a human exoskeleton — which takes on unexpected symbolic and story-fueling purpose in the film.

Annette Bening again proves her spunkiness and depth as Wiig’s single mother with a penchant for gambling. Mom is also shacking up with a presumed CIA agent/self-styled samurai played with his usual oddball flair by Matt Dillon (another somehow loveable nutcase role for his IMDB list, alongside Drugstore Cowboy and There’s Something About Mary).

But ultimately the parts are more enjoyable than the dramatic-comic whole of Girl Most Likely. Eccentric twists and stunt work try to get along with genuine emotional sentiments, sometimes giving us audience whiplash. But Wiig keeps us tuned in, a process-in-progress in her post-SNL days.

For showtimes, check the Independent's movie listings, here.

To submit a comment on this article, email or visit our Facebook page. To submit information to a reporter, email

Be succinct, constructive, and relevant to the story. Leaving a comment means you agree to our Discussion Guidelines. We like civilized discourse. We don't like spam, lying, profanity, harassment or personal attacks.

comments powered by Disqus
event calendar sponsored by:

Carousel House Now for Rent

The iconic octagon is available for parties and classes.

‘Fess Parker’ Name Dropped from Santa Barbara Waterfront Hotel

Change to Hilton Santa Barbara said to help the hotel reach a broader demographic.

Nicholas Kristof Hashes Out How To Help

The Pulitzer Prize-winning author joined local nonprofits to talk global development.

Pile Burn Season Raises Alarms

Uptick in citizen emergency calls upon viewing smoke and fire.

Jon Peterson Departs Habitat for Humanity

Takes a post with Covenant Trust Company of Chicago.